Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Climate Change Weekly #513: 📢 Hey, Ho! Biden/Harris Climate Policies Have to Go 📢

From Heartland Daily News

H. Sterling Burnett

YOU SHOULD SUBSCRIBE TO CLIMATE CHANGE WEEKLY.

IN THIS ISSUE:

  • Hey, Ho! Biden/Harris Climate Policies Have to Go
  • Video of the Week: The Truth About Islands and Sea Level Rise
  • Green Energy Schemes Are the Poor Subsidizing the Rich
  • Podcast of the Week: Climate Policy at the GOP Convention: What a Second Trump Term Could Look Like
  • New Analysis Ties Whale Deaths to Offshore Wind
  • Climate Comedy
  • Recommended Sites

Watch ALL the Presentations by the ALL-STARS of Climate Realism at the Archive of Heartland’s 15 Climate Conferences


Hey, Ho! Biden/Harris Climate Policies Have to Go

Meet the new boss, worse than the old boss! At least if you care about energy independence and household security.

As hard as it may be to believe, presumptive presidential replacement nominee, Vice President Kamala Harris, may be worse on climate and energy issues than is her current boss, President Joe Biden. I’ll explain why, shortly, but first a brief discussion of the present state of energy/climate policy.

From the outset, the Biden/Harris administration pushed an all-of-government approach to fighting climate change, which Biden, with Harris’ support and encouragement, has called the only existential threat facing humanity.

The energy policies flowing from Biden/Harris’s climate concerns have cost the people of the United States and the nation itself, dearly.

From day one, the Biden/Harris administration’s energy policies began to undermine the United States’ position of energy dominance. Biden/Harris have blocked and canceled pipelines, oil and gas leases, and lease auctions, and new liquefied natural gas export terminals. They have imposed new, stricter regulations on power plants, vehicles, and oil and gas production. In response to the market chaos and higher prices these policies have produced, Biden/Harris then began draining our various strategic reserves and begged hostile foreign regimes to provide us with energy we could produce at home—all factors which also harm our allies in Europe, who have become increasingly dependent on the United States for critical fuel.

How much have the Biden/Harris administration’s energy policies directly added to U.S. household energy bills? The Heartland Institute has found that over the past three years: residential electricity prices have increased 23 percent; home heating oil prices have increased 69 percent; oil prices have increased 52 percent; natural gas prices have increased 32 percent; and gasoline has increased $0.97 per gallon, or 42 percent.

The result? After three years of Biden/Harris energy policies, the average U.S. driver has spent at least an extra $548 per year on gasoline, and the average household has expended an extra $318 on electricity per year. In sum, since Biden/Harris assumed the office of Imperial Executive—imposing energy policies through regulations and bans, skipping legislative action—the average American household directly paid at least $2,548 in higher direct energy costs from January 2021 through December 2023, meaning the actual added costs of energy have been even greater since prices have continued to rise in the seven months since then.

Also, that doesn’t even count the trillions of tax dollars and deficit spending on climate change boondoggles that reward Biden/Harris’s politically connected green energy profiteers.

Although it is true that the rate of rise in energy prices has fallen in the last year, they are still going up and are much higher across the board than they were under Trump. Indeed, under Trump, oil and gasoline prices fell from Obama/Biden administration levels, and electric power prices were rising at a much slower annual rate than they are now (and the electric power supply was much more reliable with fewer blackouts and brownouts).

And since energy is a factor in almost every good and service, higher energy prices contributed to the rising prices seen in virtually all goods and services, especially food prices, while spurring inflation. So, when you pay more for bread, milk, and other food staples at the grocery store and your paycheck, or food stamps, don’t buy as much as they used to, or when you pay more at restaurants for your meal, you can give an angry, “Thanks a lot, Biden/Harris, for the higher costs, leaving us with less disposable income and fewer choices.”

The repeated chants of “drill, baby, drill,” calls for a return to U.S. energy independence, and sporadic references to the “climate hoax” at the recent Republican National Convention in Milwaukee served notice that Republicans remember what lower fuel prices were like and how they resulted in a growing economy, with good paying jobs, and lower costs for everything else, including food, since energy costs are part of everything.

However, the higher costs resulting from the Biden/Harris energy policies—polices Harris has bragged about—do not respect political affiliation: rather they hurt Democrats, Independents, and Republicans alike.

Indeed, a recent Heartland/Rasmussen survey of likely voters nationwide found that more people support expanding oil and gas production in the country than believe that the Earth is suffering from dangerous climate change, and few people are willing to pay very much to fight climate change.

And it’s not just Republicans that long for more domestic oil and gas production. The Heartland/Rasmussen poll found that more Democrats favor increased domestic oil and gas production than oppose it. Republicans and Independents favor more drilling by and even wider margin.

The fact that a large plurality of Democrats support increased oil and gas production is especially interesting since, according to the same survey, 75 percent of them believe “the [E]arth is experiencing a dangerous level of climate change,” with more than half attributing the dangerous climate primarily to human actions.

If climate change is such an important crisis, one must wonder why so many Democrats support increased oil and gas production, which Biden/Harris and company blame for climate change.

Perhaps they recognize, as Republicans and a large number of Independents do, that the Biden/Harris administration’s climate efforts have not just resulted in higher prices, rippling throughout the economy, but also has resulted in leaving the country economically and geopolitically vulnerable to our competitors and enemies. Or perhaps, like most normal people, they are simply worried about bottom-line pocketbook issues.

As horrible as the impact of Biden/Harris’s climate and energy policies on peoples’ pocketbooks has been thus far, based on her past statements, the climate and energy policies flowing from a Harris/whoever ticket are likely to be even worse. As my colleague Chris Talgo pointed out in a recent article, Harris is even more radical than President Biden when it comes to energy policy.

As attorney general of California, Harris brought multiple lawsuits against oil companies trying to sue them, if not out of existence, at least into subservience to political masters. She’s also been a staunch opponent of offshore oil drilling, called for a complete ban on fracking, endorsed a tax on carbon dioxide emissions, and has thrown strong support to electric vehicle mandates and renewable energy subsidies with the goal of making the U.S. economy “carbon neutral” in just a few decades.

Indeed, Harris’s plans seem less intended to prevent climate change than to assert federal control over the entire economy. The evidence for this is that, as a senator, she was an original co-sponsor of the radical Green New Deal, an effort lead by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), which her chief of staff, Saikat Chakrabarti, described as a “how-do-you-change-the-entire economy thing.”

This isn’t a partisan issue. America can’t afford another four more years of Harris/whoever’s energy policies that leave people with less money in their pockets and leave the country vulnerable to the whims of foreign powers.

Sources: The Heartland Institute; Townhall; Heartland/Rasmussen Poll


NEW: Get Climate at a Glance on your mobile device!


Video of the Week

The Heartland Institute’s Linnea Lueken examines the claim that island nations like Tuvalu are threatened with disaster because of modestly rising sea levels associated with climate change. The complicated and non-alarmist truth is here.


Green Energy Schemes Are the Poor Subsidizing the Rich

New research published by the National Bureau of Economic Research finds that the vast bulk of the $47 billion in tax credits for green energy technologies, like electric vehicles, roof-top solar panels, high efficiency appliances, and energy efficient window installations, between 2006 and 2021, have been claimed by households in the highest income brackets. In other words, the subsidies amounted to welfare for the well to do.

As The Daily Caller describes the study’s results, “households in the top 20 percent of earnings nationally received about 60 percent of clean energy tax credits, while the bottom 60 percent of households received just 10 percent.”

The paper is authored by Severin Borenstein, Ph.D., the E.T. Grether Professor of Business Administration and Public Policy at the Haas School of Business and a research associate of the Energy Institute in the Haas School at the University of California–Berkeley, and Lucas W. Davis, Ph.D. a distinguished professor and chair of the Haas Economic Analysis and Policy Group at UC–Berkeley.

With regard to EV tax credits, Borenstein and Davis found the top 20 percent of earners claimed 80 percent of the tax credits, with those in the top 5 percent of incomes garnering about 50 percent of the credits by themselves. Seriously, billionaires and multimillionaires need tax credits to purchase electric vehicles?

Indeed, the study found limited “correlation between greater green tax credits and the adoption of technology such as heat pumps, solar panels, and EVs.”

“The cost effectiveness of tax credits hinges on their ability to increase adoption of clean energy technologies,” the study noted. “Overall, we find little correlation between tax credits and technology adoption.”

This means, in short, the rich claimed tax credits they didn’t need, since they would likely have bought the green energy tech without them. Increasing various green energy tax credits did not increase or broaden adoption. The poor who couldn’t afford (or didn’t really desire the technology) before the credits, still couldn’t afford them (or didn’t want them) after support was increased. For heat pumps, for example, the authors concluded:

[A] credit was introduced in 2006, yet adoption decreased in that year. The credit was not available in 2008 and 2018, but there is no discernible decline in heat pump shipments during those years. Moreover, during 2009 and 2010 the credit increased from 10% to 30%, yet there is no pronounced increase in heat pump shipments those years.

Sources: The Daily Caller;  National Bureau of Economic Research


Heartland’s Must-read Climate Sites


Podcast of the Week

As the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee closed, we look at the climate and energy platform of the party. Do they differ from Trump’s first-term agenda? What is the stance of VP candidate J.D. Vance on the topic considering Trump has tapped Vance to carry his MAGA agenda forward? To talk about all this – plus the Crazy Climate News of the Week – we have as our guest Steve Milloy of JunkScience.com who was a member of the EPA Transition Team for the first Trump presidency.

Subscribe to the Environment & Climate News podcast on Apple Podcasts, iHeart, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. And be sure to leave a positive review!


New Analysis Ties Whale Deaths to Offshore Wind

A story in The Daily Mail  references new research concerning the increase in whale deaths off the eastern coast of the United States. The research strongly indicates that the timing and number of whale deaths so closely correlates in time and location to the commencement of and expansion of sonar mapping for industrial offshore wind projects that the scientist undertaking the research says with confidence, “Absolutely, 100 percent, offshore wind kills whales.”

Apostolos Gerasoulis, a Rutgers University professor emeritus of computer science, who co-created the search engine that powers Ask.com, was shocked by the uptick in whale and marine mammal deaths in recent years and developed a software system to “identify any relationship between the dead whales and offshore wind survey vessels, which use loud blasts of sonar to map the seabed for the installation of offshore wind turbines and high-voltage cables.” He named the system Luna, in honor of a popular humpback whale researchers tracked migrating up and down the eastern seaboard for nearly 50 years, but which had washed ashore, dead, recently.

Beginning in 2016, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration declared “unusual mortality events” for humpback whales and in 2017 for minke whales and North Atlantic right whales, when deaths of the species spiked after years of stable or flat mortality. Since 2016, 534 of those species of whales have died; many hundreds and perhaps thousands of more marine mammals, including dolphins and porpoises, are also believed to have died over the same time period.

The spike in deaths corresponded to the commencement of broad sonar mapping of the U.S. East Coast in anticipation of the construction of offshore wind farms, beginning in 2016. These vessels send out loud, high-intensity sonar blasts to map the ocean floor to determine suitable locations for offshore wind farms turbines. The Daily Mail  notes:

The underwater noise is loud. On May 8, 2023, Robert Rand, a veteran acoustical consultant conducted a study of the sonar noise generated by the Miss Emma McCall survey vessel off the coast of New Jersey.

The following January, he testified at a Congressional hearing about his findings.

Rand found that the sound was 224 decibels at the source. As sound waves travel away from the source, volume diminishes. But a half nautical mile away, Rand measured peak sound levels at 151.6 decibels.

The National Marine Fisheries Service, part of NOAA, says that whales and other marine mammals can temporarily lose hearing at 152 decibels of continuous sound and can permanently lose hearing at 173 decibels.

Commenting on those findings, a conservation biologist interviewed for the story, Trisha DeVoe, told The Daily Mail:

There’s a saying that a deaf whale is a dead whale. Because if the whale can’t hear, it can’t see to navigate. The depths of the ocean are very dark, and they rely on their hearing to know what’s around them.

If all of a sudden there’s this incredibly loud, disturbing noise that could even be painful to them, they’re going to run away. So we think that it could be deafening them or causing them to flee, and then maybe putting them in harm’s way.

Gerasoulis’s software seems to confirm the thought that high frequency solar blasts are harming whales.

NOAA data show that whale deaths off the coasts of New Jersey, New York, and Rhode Island jumped five-fold, from an average of two per year before 2016 to 10 or more per year in the years since, with 21 humpback whales dying in the region in 2023 alone.

The Luna system plots whale deaths, accounts for wave action, and tracks the mileage and paths logged by survey ships as they travel zigzag courses during mapping, generating a system of maps that display the locations of whale deaths alongside the routes taken by various survey ships. The Daily Mail   described some of the specific results:

[F]rom 2017 through 2023, a total of 286 whales, dolphins, and porpoises died along the New Jersey and New York shores. Luna shows exactly where they were found.

Luna visually displays the zigzag routes taken by offshore wind survey vessels. During January and February 2022, there was little survey boat [traffic] in the area. Six vessels traveled a total of 4,213 miles. One humpback whale died.

January and February 2023, however, showed a tremendous increase in survey vessel traffic in the waters off New Jersey and New York – 13 vessels traveled a total of 11,977 miles. Seven humpback whales died, including Luna.

In August 2022, survey boat traffic was minimal off the New Jersey coast. Two survey vessels worked near Asbury Park and two more worked off Atlantic City. They traveled a total of 5,469 miles. There was plenty of open water around the two survey areas and no humpback whales died.

August 2023, however, was a different story. Sixteen different offshore wind survey vessels moved slowly back and forth off the coast. They covered a total of 16,812 miles, triple the amount of the previous August. Six whales died that month.

Gerasoulis also accounted for the increase and decline in ship traffic during the survey period and found there was no correlation between increased ship traffic and increases in whale deaths.

To test the robustness of Luna’s connection between whale deaths and offshore wind activities, Gerasoulis put the data through two statistical analyses. He divided his data into the number of humpback whale deaths from 2006 to 2015 in the areas of study, and the number of whale deaths after 2016 when offshore wind surveys were underway. Both analyses confirmed “that the difference in whale deaths before and after offshore wind surveys started was statistically significant and not random.”

Based on these results, Gerasoulis says NOAA should rethink its claim that wind facility siting and construction activities are not harming marine mammals.

“It is the cumulative impact of multiple offshore wind boats surveying in a small region where the whales are feeding that is affecting the whales,” Gerasoulis told The Daily Mail.  “NOAA needs to investigate.”

Source: The Daily Mail


Climate Comedy


Recommended Sites

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/WYnDGIQ

July 26, 2024 at 08:03PM

While the west watches a game show, the rest build a new world order

From the BOE REPORT

Terry Etam

Some very big and important things are happening in the world, and it seems that we’re not paying attention at all. We are becoming so fixated on the simple, the sensational, that we’re not noticing the storm clouds.

Now, to be clear, the ballistic winging of a high-level American politician is most deserving of our attention, particularly when the circumstances and outcome are frankly not just nearly apocalyptic but bizarre. The circumstances are so strange and run counter to our expectations that have been baked in from viewing a thousand shows of that very theme (Half the audience watched the shooter wandering around, ratting him out to the cops, who did nothing? Secret Service left the roof unguarded because it’s nearly flat structure was too dangerous for SWAT teams? Huh? And on and on.).

We are no longer in the age of the Zapruder Film, where a singular grainy video captured all we know about the Kennedy assassination. Trump’s shooting was so well documented from every angle that we have acoustic engineers taking to social media with impressively detailed analyses of where shots came from, and equally impressive counter arguments based on some other esoteric analysis of another aspect. Thus, we analyze all.

Sunlight is indeed the best disinfectant, so all these viewpoints are of value and will hinder any miscreants from hiding anything. And yet I can’t help but marvel at the tectonic shifts happening in the world, almost unnoticed in the west, or ignored in the west, that are rearranging the global geopolitical landscape in significant ways, for decades to come, and it’s like we’re not even paying attention. 

The biggest, quietest movement must the the rise of BRICS, the affiliation of nine countries that have formed an alliance to ‘counter western influence’ and work to chart a new direction. The founding countries – Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa – were joined by new members at the beginning of the year, including Egypt, Ethiopia, the UAE, and Saudi Arabia (who has been coy about explicitly affirming membership but is considered member last I checked). These countries are not a chain of unpopulated tropical islands; they have a combined population of about 3.5 billion people and annual GDP of over $28 trillion. 

The BRICS group is growing quickly; earlier this year, it was reported that an additional 34 countries have expressed an interest in joining, with many applications from Africa, South America and Asia. It would not be hard to envision Russian satellite countries looking that way as well.

What makes the rise of this group so significant is that the west has charged down an economic/socioeconomic path that is reliant on at least some BRICS members/applicants (Saudi Arabia, various African countries with critical minerals, and above all China who controls the world’s metals processing capability to an alarming degree). The west is envisioning an energy transition in the next few decades that will be, to put it mildly, heavily dependent on this group’s output and capabilities.

There are two big problems arising here. One is exemplified by Europe, which is successfully reducing emissions in large part by de-industrializing and offshoring anything dirty to the developing world (then getting upset about their emissions). 

The other is the fact that the west gets apoplectic at the sight of this group frolicking in the sun without putting the west’s wishes first. For example, the west has heavily (and imo justifiably) sanctioned Russia over the attack on Ukraine, in an attempt to cripple Russia’s economy. Sanctions include a price cap on Russian oil, a tactic that was roundly mocked as having no hope of being effective by seasoned oil market analysts, but nevertheless, a sanction meant to show that the world was serious and united. 

But then a few weeks ago, India’s Prime Minister Modi paid a visit to the demon himself, Vladimir Putin, on Russian soil, and was greeted with a big hug (the hug was reciprocated; the humiliation for Putin otherwise would have been unbearable). “Why is Modi sucking up to Putin? It’s simple and cynical: China and Oil” snorted the UK’s Guardian through socialist and imperialist nostrils. The Guardian article is snide, provincial, and reeks of the arrogance of the once-relevant that won’t recognize the ‘once-‘ : “Modi knows well how to opportunistically turn someone else’s war to his advantage.” (Such pompous piffle isn’t unique; in 2023, the Economist’s editor-in-chief Manny Zinton Beddoes introduced an Economist article that explained “why the Middle East still matters to the world.” Note the complex arrogance embedded in that comment, that it is or has been a reasonable question as to whether the Middle East matters, and that you, as a dimwitted reader, will need some pedigreed ponce to explain to you the ‘why’. Go back to the 19th century.)

But anyway, step back and consider what the west is focused on, versus what the rest of the world is focused on. We follow the minutiae of sheer crap like Taylor Swift’s love life or George Clooney’s open letter about old man Biden like it is worthy of something; BRICS countries are quietly rearranging the furniture and changing the locks on the doors. We demand the world switch to ‘green initiatives’ like EVs, then slam the doors on Chinese EVs that would make them affordable to North Americans and hasten a transition. 

I’m not sweeping under the rug any of Putin’s considerable transgressions, or commenting at all on China’s strategic moves that may not align with Western ideals. They do what they do internally, and we can’t do anything about that. The point is that all of this is going on and we pretend it isn’t, because we don’t like the players or the game. 

Nowhere is this more evident than with respect to energy. Five years ago, we in the hydrocarbon sector had to listen to ignorant grandstanding blowhards explain, without a shred of energy knowledge, that hydrocarbons were so last-century, that there was no need or role for natural gas in an energy transition, that oil demand peaked in 2019 and would never recover. Every one of these dumbass claims lies trampled in the dust, and there has been not an iota of soul-searching or admission of error or recalibration; all we see is a doubling down on the same dumb thinking that went into the first cocktail of wild-eyed projections (go figure; the zealots strong-armed the International Energy Agency into an energy-transition propaganda  powerhouse, forcing them to behave as some sort of macro support dog as their leg of ‘science’. It’s no wonder they have not much to say when the results are so hopelessly far off the mark from what they were wishing for.)

Related to energy is the auto industry, where calamity now reigns supreme. Western automakers were ensured that consumers were going to switch en masse to EVs – not hybrids, but EVs – because governments were going to make them. Many countries including Canada have legislated internal combustion engines out of existence past dates in the mid 2030s. So all you SUV-spewing auto companies, get on with the transition. 29dk2902lhttps://boereport.com/29dk2902l.html

Fine, they all said, and set about building EV manufacturing facilities and battery plants. Five billion here, ten billion there, and they’re off and running, ready for governmental zero-emissions mandates. Then, a scant few years into the forced migration, a few unforeseen developments arose (not really unforeseen, more like ‘wished away’, they should have been obvious…). Consumers became lukewarm on the whole EV idea, and have decided hybrids are what they really want. Now, big players like Ford are scrambling to get more hybrids to market (wise ones like Toyota never bought into the whole idea in the first place, and now have a hybrid version of every vehicle). 

On the EV front, imagine that, China took their battery and metals processing dominance, their growing engineering prowess, and all the tricks they’ve learned from forced JVs with western companies and began a global flood of reasonably priced and well-built EVs. (China, in 2018, net imported $30 billion worth of autos. In 2023, they net exported $80 billion, and climbing rapidly. Some turnaround.) Now the west is panicking because of what those machines could do to home market manufacturers, and they’re caught between a rock and a hard place: consumers are reluctant to switch to EVs in large part because of cost, and while Chinese firms have solved the cost problem, western governments can’t allow them to decimate native industries, and are thus excluding Chinese EVs from their markets via huge tariffs. China is undeterred, and, coming back full circle to the BRICS story, is developing vast markets for their products in developing countries. 

The 3.5 billion BRICS people, plus a few billion more around the edges, are finding their feet, their strength, and their voice, and saying either overtly or via trade deals that “We think we can get along on our own, thanks anyway.”

This reworking of the global order should be front page news, as it is going to be rather cataclysmic for the golden billion. Haha. Get real. Good luck for that story to fight its way in front of the dancing bears. Another example: As mentioned, about ten days ago, Donald Trump came within an inch or two of being murdered live on national media. Kind of a big deal. And yet that story has been pushed from the front pages by what should be the most obvious and anticlimactic story imaginable, that an 81-year old with severely diminishing mental capacity stepped down from the most powerful seat in the world. Gee, who saw that coming. 

And next week will be an damning/hilarious/embarrassing/brilliant (ok scratch brilliant)/ridiculous video clip of Kamala or Donald or some grandstanding political boob, and we’ll watch it 50 million times and argue about it like our lives depend on it, and in the background China will quietly sign billions of dollars of development deals with developing countries; Russia, Iran, India and many others will continue strengthening cooperative channels that the west pretends doesn’t exist (we do see it: “Growing Cooperation Between Russia and China in Arctic, Pentagon Says” reports Reuters, and that the US, Canada, and Norway hope to sign a deal by year end to begin the process of building new icebreakers at some time in the next decade or two, at the regulatory speed these things work), and the frog will find at some point that the water is too hot to leap out of. And the North Korean flat top is going to be next year’s Gangnam Style must see. That we’d watch.

What the world desperately needs – energy clarity. And a few laughs. Pick up The End of Fossil Fuel Insanity,  available at Amazon.ca, Indigo.ca, or Amazon.com.

Read more insightful analysis from Terry Etam here, or email Terry here.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/oJaSHs7

July 26, 2024 at 04:06PM

Quadrupled Border Crossings

Illegal border crossings quadrupled immediately after Kamala Harris was put in charge of slowing them down. Why Illegal Border Crossings Are So High – The New York Times “A senior administration official said Harris’ role would focus on “two tracks”: … Continue reading →

via Real Climate Science

https://ift.tt/6Boc8Ch

July 26, 2024 at 03:23PM

I Wrote an Article for Forbes Defending J.D. Vance From Accusations of ‘Climate Denialism’. Forty-Eight Hours Later, Forbes Un-Published the Article and Sacked Me as a Contributor

From THE DAILY SCEPTIC

by Tilak Doshi

An article I wrote for Forbes about J.D. Vance published on July 18th began as follows: 

Within a day of ex-President Trump’s announcement of “climate denier” Mr. J. D. Vance as the Republican Vice Presidential nominee, the climate industrial complex and supportive mainstream media had the knives out.

Little did I know that within a day of publishing that article, the knives would come out for me. 

The editors of Forbes deleted my article, stating that “we had to take down your latest Forbes article about J.D. Vance because it did not meet our editorial guidelines which we take seriously”. This was followed by a short note stating that I was sacked as a contributor. Similar complaints of not abiding by the magazine’s guidelines were made by an editor on a couple of previous published articles. 

What editorial guidelines? “Avoid advocacy, opinion, polemic and rumour-mongering.” 

I have yet to read any Forbes piece that avoided opinion, given that Forbes contributors are opinion columnists and not journalists who are hired to merely report the news. The contributor’s role, one would have thought, is to offer opinions and advocate certain lines of argument about current affairs or topics of interest based on a reasonable reading of verifiable data. Otherwise, what is the contributor’s purpose? 

But here is the catch. It depends on whether you are “on message”. Are you with or against the accepted narratives? If against, you are cancelled. That is how the establishment operates – within Forbes and in the mainstream media – as I found out. 

“Avoid Advocacy”

Here is the lead paragraph of a recent article in Forbes entitled “GOP Platform: Back To The Carbon Age” in the weekly column “Current Climate” by two “Forbes Senior Editors”:

Ahead of the Republican Party’s National Convention that kicks off today in Milwaukee, the GOP released its official platform of key priorities for a second potential Trump Administration. As with any such political document, it’s long on platitudes and slogans, but very short on detail. But there’s at least one clear takeaway in the document: it prioritises increasing energy from fossil fuels while ignoring the carbon-fuelled climate crisis that’s triggered record-setting heatwaves and earlier and more intense hurricanes. 

The authors assert that the GOP official platform “prioritises increasing energy from fossil fuels while ignoring the carbon-fuelled climate crisis”. They further claim that the “carbon-fuelled climate crisis” has “triggered record-setting heatwaves and earlier and more intense hurricanes”. By these leading statements, the reader is led to believe that both constitute “settled science”. 

Here is another example of writing from another recently published Forbes article that allegedly does not constitute advocacy or opinion: 

Imagine not being able to get the warning about the approaching hurricane or tornado. How would you know when to evacuate to stay safe or board up your home or business? Or make sure your staff is protected? It’s not a bad dream, it could be the reality if Donald Trump takes office again.

My suggestion that the policy positions of J.D. Vance in support of fossil fuels and sceptical of climate alarmist claims are consistent with the verities of physics and economics got me cancelled. But arguing that if Donald Trump takes over, it would be “a bad dream” is perfectly fine in a Forbes world allegedly devoid of advocacy or opinion. 

Settled Science

To suggest that fossil fuels have “fuelled the climate crisis” is, we are led to believe, neither an opinion nor advocacy. Forbes’s readers are told to accept “the carbon-fuelled climate crisis” as established science, though it is nothing of the sort. There is no “settled science” – an oxymoron to begin with – regarding climate change. It is apparent that Forbes would have cancelled John Clauser, a Nobel Laureate, for Physics in 2022 – like the IMF did – since he does not give obeisance at the altar of climate change as Forbes staff evidently do along with their preferred contributors and senior editors.

Indeed, if Dr. Clauser were to write, as he did, that the climate emergency narrative is “a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world’s economy and the well-being of billions of people”, he would have received a termination letter pronto from the senior editors of Forbes. And if he had said, as he did, that “climate science has metastasised into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience”, that would certainly have sealed his fate. 

The Forbes editors seem oblivious to the fact that the latest IPCC assessment report, by finding little support for the much-proclaimed link between climate change and extreme weather events, “is badly out of step with today’s apocalyptic zeitgeist” as Roger Pielke Jr. puts it. 

What is even more remarkable is that Forbes’s senior editors seem out of step with their own Editor-in-Chief and grandson of the magazine’s founder, Steve Forbes. Mr. Forbes said in his column last month that some $6 trillion had been spent on “so-called renewables” such as solar and wind over the past two decades which “barely made a dent” in the use of fossil fuels in the global economy. Yet in the linked Forbes article above, the authors criticise the GOP platform for not making specific references to solar and wind (along with geothermal and hydropower). Perhaps they should have checked with their own Editor-in-Chief before indulging in “climate groupthink”, which Mr. Forbes warns his readers against.

Au Revoir Forbes

My first Forbes article was published more than five years ago in April 2019 entitled ‘The World Bank’s Misguided Green Energy Policies To Persist’. Since then, I have published a range of pieces on climate, energy and public policy. Readers often remarked in personal comments to me that they found it surprising that a mainstream business magazine such as Forbes allowed such contrarian and sceptical writing to be published. My response was to say that Forbes was exceptional in providing a broad range of informed opinion to their readers. 

Alas, that is no longer true, and climate groupthink has captured yet another media outlet. Newer hires at the Forbes editorial office from a younger more “woke” generation of journalists may well have tipped the balance in support of the climate alarmist narrative. Gone are the days when informed analysts such as Roger Pielke Jr., Michael Schellenberger, Diana Furchtgott-Roth graced the pages of Forbes. 

Dr. Tilak K. Doshi is an energy consultant, member of the CO2 Coalition and an ex-Forbes contributor.

Below is the article that Forbes memory-holed.

Trump’s VP Pick Is A Climate Sceptic And the Knives Are Out

By Tilak Doshi

Within a day of ex-President Trump’s announcement of “climate denier” Mr. J. D. Vance as the Republican Vice Presidential nominee, the climate industrial complex and supportive mainstream media had the knives out. A few headlines of the past 24 hours are an indication:

New York Times – “J.D. Vance Is an Oil Booster and Doubter of Human-Caused Climate Change”

Independent – J.D. Vance: “Climate Activists Alarmed by Trump’s ‘Dangerous’ Pick for Vice President”

Guardian – “Climate Advocates Fear Picking J.D. Vance for VP Is ‘A Dangerous Step Backward’”

The umbrage taken by media commentators is familiar. CNBC laments that “the former venture capitalist though is a known critic of climate change and renewable energy [italics added].” U.K.’s the Independent newspaper reports that “[c]ampaigners are responding with alarm to the selection of climate denier and Ohio senator J.D. Vance as Donald Trump’s Vice Presidential nominee, with activists warning he represents a “dangerous” voice for the U.S.” Mr. Vance’s “eagerness to please Donald Trump” adds to the image of the Vice-Presidential nominee as an unprincipled politician seeking office. 

Climate advocacy group Fossil Free Media spokesperson Cassidy DiPaola asserted that “This [VP] choice signals that a potential Trump-Vance administration would likely double down on fossil fuel expansion at a time when we desperately need to transition to clean energy.” Communications Director Stevie O’Hanlon of Sunrise Movement, a climate activist organisation, said that “Like Donald Trump, J.D. Vance has proven that he will make it a top priority to roll back climate protections while answering to the demands of oil and gas CEOs.” 

Does Mr. Vance have a principled stand and is his stance on climate and energy policy worthy of consideration?

Climate Denialism 

As the highly polarised debate over climate change over the past few decades has amply demonstrated, the discourse often descends into ad hominem attacks and name calling. “Climate denier” is a charge that is often used by proponents of climate alarm to shut down critical debate and to deplatform climate sceptics. Lena Moffitt, Executive Director of the environmental advocacy group Evergreen Action, said this of Mr. Vance: “Donald Trump has chosen an avowed climate denier as his running mate who has used his time in Congress to vote against the environment and shill for fossil fuel corporations at every opportunity.” 

The “denier” accusation is among the more pernicious if popular epithets used to denigrate sceptics of the so-called “consensus science”. It invokes a comparison to those who engage in Holocaust denial. To be sure, most observers would consider it ludicrous to suggest that questioning the accuracy and predictive power of scientific models is like questioning the historical fact of the genocide of Jews in Europe. 

What Is Mr. Vance’s Position on Climate?

Putting aside epithets and journalistic hit-pieces, it seems a fair question to ask just what do politicians sceptical of the climate alarmist narrative believe? And what are their policy positions regarding the Paris Agreement’s “Net Zero by 2050” target? This policy target is an imperative, at least nominally, for most current governments in North America and Western Europe.

Mr. Vance – lawyer, businessman, former Marine and writer of the bestselling memoir Hillbilly Elegy, arisen from the humblest working-class background – places himself firmly in the populist Right movement. It now looks very likely that Mr. Trump will be the next U.S. President. The assassination attempt on Saturday, his miraculous split-second turn of the head which saved him and the iconic picture of his raised fist with the U.S. flag in the background seconds after being injured make him almost irresistible. Thus Mr. Vance will likely join the Donald Trump next year as his VP in an administration that will seek to rapidly unwind the myriad policy and regulatory constraints that the Biden administration has imposed to shackle the U.S. oil and gas industry at every turn. 

Vance has also criticised the “green energy fantasy” of the Biden administration, pointing out that “solar panels can’t power a modern manufacturing economy” and “that’s why the Chinese are building coal power plants”. He has similarly called out wind power turbines. At the Turning Point Action conference last year, he said “they’re hideously ugly. They kill all the birds. And they’re mostly made in China.” The Biden administration’s all-out support for EVs comes in for the same critique. In a July 2022 radio interview, he said: “The whole EV thing is a scam. If you plug it into your wall, do these people think there are Keebler elves back there making electricity in the wall? It comes, of course, from fossil fuels.”

Mr. Vance’s climate scepticism goes beyond encouraging U.S. oil and gas dominance in global markets once again – a strong theme of Trump’s first term in office – if the Republicans get elected to office. He has come out fiercely against the ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance) movement. In an interview with Breitbart in 2022, he said: “ESG is basically a massive racket to enrich Wall Street and enrich the financial sector of the country, at the expense of the industries that actually employ a lot of Ohio’s workers for middle-class jobs.” The push against ESG occurring through the red states in the U.S. and the increasingly evident lack of success of ESG-focused firms and investment advisors suggests that Mr. Vance has probably got a better finger on the pulse than his critics would care to admit.

Who’s More Credible?

As a climate change sceptic, Mr. Vance stands in good company. For instance, the 2022 Nobel Laureate in Physics John Clauser exposed in a recent lecture how the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) models and analyses do not meet basic standards of scientific enquiry. IPCC models have been used as “proof” of scientific consensus by politicians and activists to support claims of a “climate crisis”. Another example would be Richard Lindzen, an American atmospheric physicist and Emeritus Professor of Meteorology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who published an assessment of the global warming narrative in 2022. Prof. Lindzen finds climate alarmism “a quasi-religious movement predicated on an absurd ‘scientific’ narrative. The policies invoked on behalf of this movement have led to the U.S. hobbling its energy system.” Whatever one’s views on climate science, it is apparent that Mr. Vance is not a wild-eyed outlier in his scepticism of the claims of climate policy advocates, as asserted by his many critics. 

J.D. Vance’s criticisms of subsidy-supported renewable energy and EV sectors accord with the empirical evidence emerging in the current context of higher inflation, higher interest rates and a deep slump in renewable energy stocks. For instance, an Associated Press report last November described the travails of the Biden administration’s ambitious plans for offshore wind: “The cancellation of two large offshore wind projects in New Jersey is the latest in a series of setbacks for the nascent U.S. offshore wind industry, jeopardising the Biden administration’s goals of powering 10 million homes from towering ocean-based turbines by 2030 and establishing a carbon-free electric grid five years later.” This news was preceded by earlier reports of developers cancelling three offshore wind power projects in New England. They said their projects were “no longer financially feasible” despite the ample subsidies on offer.

The news on the EV front, called out as a “scam” by Mr. Vance, is just as dire for green technology enthusiasts. As David Blackmon, a keen observer of the renewable energy space, notes: surveys show that the vast majority of U.S. car buyers will not purchase an EV even at “bargain basement” prices (and despite Government subsidies); the overall growth in private EV sales in the U.S. has slowed “to a trickle”, just as is happening in the U.K. and EU; and the market for used EVs is practically non-existent. “Pure play” EV maker Fisker recently declared bankruptcy while Rivian approaches the same fate. Giant U.S. automakers GM and Ford have turned to gasoline-powered vehicles to sustain their profits as the global EV sales slowdown force them to delay investments and cut costs in their EV production lines.

Partisans may criticise the man all they want, but the realities of thermodynamics and economics support J.D. Vance. He may prove to be the best Vice President in a Republican administration geared towards supporting the country’s oil and gas industries and ‘Making America Great Again’.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/Orm3C0k

July 26, 2024 at 01:04PM