Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Net zero will only make you poorer and China richer-Bjorn Lomborg

By Paul Homewood

 

image

Starting in the 1990s, climate change has become a fixation for rich country politicians and elites. It emerged as the world had just seen the end of the Cold War. There was relative peace and trust across the world, broad economic growth, and swift progress being made against poverty. In the capitals of Europe in particular, it felt like most of the planet’s big problems were fixed, so climate change was the final frontier.

These proponents of climate action advocated with relish the goal of ending reliance on the very fossil fuels that had powered two centuries of astonishing growth. Sure, this would cost hundreds of trillions of dollars, but there would always be more growth.

What a naïve, narrow-minded world view. Time has not been kind to the foolish idea that climate change was humanity’s sole remaining problem – or that the planet would unite to solve it. Geopolitics and economics mean a rapid global transition from fossil fuels is impossible.

As has long been clear for many, the majority of the world never shared this myopic focus on climate change. Despite immense progress, in some countries life remains a battle against poverty, hunger, and disease. In many more countries including India, the top priority is to create more jobs and life-changing growth and development. Outside the most advanced economies, climate change has understandably always been a relatively low voter priority.

Leaders from Europe and the United States talk up “net zero” as though it has global support. But this unity is quickly revealed as a mirage. For one thing, the destabilizing axis of Russia, Iran and North Korea are not about to support western efforts to solve climate change. Indeed, according to McKinsey, achieving the net-zero target would require Russian climate policies costing $273 billion every year – around three-times what Russia spent on its military last year. That won’t happen.

The geopolitical challenges run even deeper. China’s growth has relied on burning ever more coal. It is the world’s preeminent greenhouse gas emitter, with the largest increase of any nation last year. Renewable energy made 40 per cent of China’s primary energy in 1971, reducing to 7 per cent by 2011 as it ramped up coal use. Since then, renewables have inched up to 10 per cent. Strong climate action could cost China nearly a trillion dollars annually, hurting its journey toward becoming a rich nation.

The reality is that most of the world – including powerhouse India and emerging economies – will continue to focus on becoming richer, often with fossil fuels. Russia and its ilk will ignore the fixation on climate change altogether. And China will make money from selling the West solar panels and electric cars, while only modestly curbing its own emissions.

As rich countries irresponsibly attempt to export the cost of climate policy to poor countries through carbon adjustment taxes, they will drive a further wedge into an already fractured world.

Meanwhile, despite all the hype, wealthy countries have ever less money left for the climate fight. Annual growth per person among rich countries declined from 4 per cent in the 1960s to 2 per cent in the 1990s. It now hovers just above one percent. Many of these countries face pressure to spend more on defense, healthcare and infrastructure, as geopolitical pressures and changing demographics make their pathway to stability and growth far less certain.

Yet, across Europe and North America, single-minded zealots who were born of a world of relative calm of the 1990s continue to push for deindustrialization and immiseration to tackle climate change – including for the world’s emerging economies.

This attempt is doomed to failure, not least because carbon reductions need to be sustained across decades and through shifting majorities. The economics of strong climate action was always deficient – and today this is blatantly obvious. More politicians are realizing what former UK energy and net-zero secretary Claire Coutinho acknowledged: “you cannot heap costs onto struggling families to meet climate targets.”

Already in Europe, voters are turning on politicians who have argued for less growth and prosperity in the name of climate change. With six to seven election cycles before mid-century, strong climate policies that could cost each person in the rich world more than ten thousand dollars a year are doomed. These policies will make it more likely that voters turn to populist, nationalist leaders that will entirely abandon expensive net zero targets. Then, climate policy will be in tatters.

The world needs a better way forward. The best solution is not to push people to be worse off by forcing a premature transition from fossil fuels to inadequate green alternatives. Instead, we should ramp up investments in green innovation, eventually driving down the cost of clean energy to be cheaper than fossil fuels. This is much cheaper and will allow everyone, including India and other emerging economies, to want to make the shift.

Rich countries need to wake up and stop hemorrhaging trillions in self-inflicted climate policies that will be followed by few, laughed at by many, and will mainly make China rich. Spending a small fraction of the climate trillions on green innovation would fix climate change. This will allow us to focus the rest of our resources on education, defense, health care and the many other, important challenges in the 21st century.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/07/24/net-zero-will-only-make-you-poorer-and-china-richer/

via NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

https://ift.tt/QmXp8Bx

July 25, 2024 at 07:40AM

1-Minute Junking: Emissions increase rainfall in Houston?

Related links: Washington Post article | Emissions warm the ocean? |WaPo & Rockefeller Foundation | WaPo and 3M

via JunkScience.com

https://ift.tt/XQNfGU7

July 25, 2024 at 06:06AM

Scraping the Bottom of the Barrel

Yesterday the Guardian’s campaign against the developed world’s wealth continued unabated. I was surprised by the heading in a profoundly campaigning article since it didn’t chime with what I understood to be the case: “Revealed: wealthy western countries lead in global oil and gas expansion – The US and the UK among countries with low dependence on fossil fuels criticized for ‘hypocrisy’ on climate pledges”. I was aware that the Biden administration in the USA, for all its claims about the Inflation Reduction Act and its supposed “green” credentials, has licensed a lot of oil and gas exploration. However, the ongoing campaign by “green” campaigners in the UK against North Sea oil and gas exploration, a Conservative government that was always at best luke-warm about exploiting these declining reserves, and a new Labour government that is profoundly hostile to them, made me wonder at the deliberate inclusion of the UK in the headline. I was also aware that the greatest growth in fossil fuel use and extraction is in the Asia-Pacific region, while countries in Latin America and Africa are also keen to exploit their fossil fuel reserves, so I was surprised by the lack of focus on those areas.

So much for the eye-catching and anti-western heading. What did the article itself say?

The claims

A surge in new oil and gas exploration in 2024 threatens to unleash nearly 12bn tonnes of planet-heating emissions, with the world’s wealthiest countries – such as the US and the UK – leading a stampede of fossil fuel expansion in spite of their climate commitments, new data shared exclusively with the Guardian reveals.

The article concentrates on the number of licences issued in 2023, at 825 said to be the largest number since records began (we aren’t told when records began). The UK, USA, Canada, Norway and Australia are categorised as being responsible for 67% of all new oil and gas licences issued globally since 2020. This claim (as I indicated above) didn’t surprise me:

Under the Biden administration, the US has handed out 1,453 new oil and gas licences, accounting for half of the total globally and 83% of all licences handed out by wealthy nations. This is 20% more than during the term of Donald Trump, who has promised to “drill, baby, drill” should he return to the White House.

In a scraping the barrel sort of way, we are told rather desperately that in May 2024 the UK granted more oil and gas licences than any other country, though it is grudgingly conceded that “it is China, the world’s leading carbon emitter, that is forecast to approve the most oil and gas blocks in the rest of 2024.”

I am always suspicious of cherry-picked statistics cited without any context. So far we have been referred to the number of licences issued since 2020, and the number of licences issued in 2023, and the number of licences issued in the UK in May 2024. However, the focus on numbers of licences issued rather obscures the issue of how much oil and gas (and resultant greenhouse gas emissions) will follow from these licences. Read on far enough, and the truth is buried deep in the article:

The newly licensed reserves in rich countries – which are smaller and harder to reach because the larger reserves have already been exploited – could eventually generate 172m tonnes of CO2, the equivalent that would be produced by 43 new coal plants.

The reality as to what is going on elsewhere in the world is also revealed:

The world’s consumption of fossil fuels climbed to a record high last year…PetroChina, the Chinese state-owned oil and gas arm, has spent the most on both exploration and well development over the past decade…

Given all this, I wonder why the Guardian hates the west so much. The truth is revealed a bit further on – it’s all to do with an ongoing grievance about how ineffective the whole COP process is, with its vague and woolly promises, but no binding obligations and precious little action:

The data reveals a deep-seated inequity – and a key climate justice issue – that developing countries have for years tried to raise at the annual UN climate talks. In order to honour their legally binding [sic] obligations under the Paris agreement, developed countries must go first when it comes to phasing out fossil fuels, starting immediately, and stopping expansion plans.

Those, then, are the claims. Finding out the truth isn’t so easy, since the claims are said to be based on “new data shared exclusively with the Guardian”. Shared exclusively, and with no link offered to readers so that they may analyse the data themselves. However, the article does refer to “analysis of industry data by the International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD)”, so I visited the website of the IISD, and what I found casts a very interesting light on the highly selective claims made above.

The reality

The most up-to-date information I was able to find on the IISD website is contained in a piece of research with this heading: “July Edition – Carbon Minefields Oil and Gas Exploration Monitor”. It tells us that :

This newsletter provides monthly updates on oil and gas expansion globally. It monitors the climate impact of countries issuing exploration licences and companies sinking capital into exploration activities.

That sounds pretty much what I am looking for. Let’s see what it says. You can satisfy yourself that I am not emulating the Guardian and cherry-picking information to support my case, by following the link above. I will highlight what I take to be the main points. The introductory paragraph could hardly be further removed from the attention-grabbing headline adopted by the Guardian:

In the past month, 18 oil and gas exploration licences were granted in six different countries. The total carbon emissions projected to be produced from burning the reserves encompassed in all the licences across the six countries amounted to 14.7 million tonnes of CO2. While Russia awarded only three licences, the combustion of their estimated oil and gas reserves would emit 10.9 MtCO2, by far the most of any country last month. China awarded the most licences, which included 2.7 million barrels of oil and 13.2 billion cubic feet of gas.

In terms of the embedded emissions associated with the licences granted by those six countries, it is evident that Russia is way out in front – streets ahead of the others – while China is in second place, followed (in order) by Equatorial Guinea, Angola, USA and Australia.

As for existing licences:

A total of 1,922.7 MtCO2 would result from burning the oil and gas reserves that were licensed over the last 12 months. May 2024 saw the largest amounts of oil and gas volumes awarded, representing more than 600 MtCO2. However, in December 2023, a higher number of smaller licences were awarded, with a total of 673 granted in this month. The countries awarding the licences with the highest estimated volume of embodied emissions are typically those with low capacity to transition away from oil and gas production and a high dependence on these fuels. This category includes Angola, Republic of Congo, Oman, Russia, and Timor-Leste. The country that awarded the largest volumes of oil and gas over the past 12 months was Mozambique, with just five new licences in May 2024. Mozambique does not yet get sufficient revenues to classify as highly dependent but is betting on the sector for its economic development.

The accompanying table shows the top ten countries in this category, in declining order according to the embedded emissions associated with the licences issued. When studying this table, it becomes obvious why the Guardian opted to focus on the number of licences issued rather than on the volumes of fossil fuels and associated greenhouse gas emissions stemming from those licences. The country with the greatest volume of associated emissions is Mozambique, followed by Russia – between them they account more than half of the emissions associated with the top ten countries. Yet Mozambique would appear in 8th place if the listing was carried out based on the number of licences issued. The UK is tenth in the list, with emissions representing just over 2.4% of the emissions associated with the top ten countries. However, in terms of the number of licences issued, the UK would be third in the list, ahead of Russia (which issued one licence less over the timescale covered by the report, despite Russia being in second place by embedded emissions). For the sake of completeness, the top ten, by volume of associated emissions are (in order): Mozambique, Russia, Egypt, Norway, USA, Angola, Trinidad and Tobago, Brazil, Israel, UK.

As for ongoing and upcoming licensing rounds:

As of last month, there were 22 blocks open for bidding or under evaluation for oil and gas exploration. Looking ahead, upcoming licensing rounds are expected to offer a total of 401 blocks for exploration in 2024. The estimated global emissions resulting from burning the fuel reserves in these upcoming rounds is a staggering 8,407.6 MtCO2. Among these rounds, China leads with the highest number of oil and gas reserves within these blocks that have the potential to generate 1,654.7 MtCO2 if exploited.

Looking to the future (which, after all, is all that we can hope to control) the picture is very different indeed. Of the five developed countries pummelled so mercilessly by the Guardian article, only the USA features (in fourth place) in the list of the top ten countries by associated greenhouse gas emissions. In order, the top ten countries are: China, Mexico, Russia, United States, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Nigeria, Indonesia, Bangladesh, Egypt.

Concluding with global exploration trends, we learn:

Emerging economies such as Brazil have also significantly ramped up their exploration activities. Petrobras has acquired the biggest share of over 200 billion barrels of oil equivalent licensed in Brazil over the last 12 months. This represents about 90 MtCO2 of additional carbon emissions that risk being released into the atmosphere. Brazil is also expected to continue licensing new fields and has decided to keep bidding rounds open indefinitely.

In the United Kingdom, on the other hand, a newly elected government has pledged not to issue any new exploration licences. This development, among others, led Rystad to lower its forecasted estimates for 2024. 

Conclusion

Shame on you Guardian. Stop gaslighting us.

via Climate Scepticism

https://ift.tt/2Npyude

July 25, 2024 at 05:08AM

How the failure of carbon capture risks causing a net zero nightmare

From NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

By Paul Homewood

.

h/t Philip Bratby

.

Meanwhile Miliband’s plans to rely on carbon capture are in ruins:

Ed Miliband has promised to drastically speed up Britain’s net zero transition but the scale of the task facing the Energy Secretary was laid bare in a damning report from the National Audit Office (NAO), published on Tuesday.

Officials told the Energy Secretary that a staggering £630m of taxpayer cash has been spent on carbon capture technology that is still years from working.

Not only did they point to the amount of investment at risk, but also stressed that the Government’s overarching goal to capture up to 30m tonnes of CO2 by 2030 is way off track.

Driving this underperformance is the fact that four key carbon capture projects are already years behind schedule, the NAO said, which is without recognising the untested technology and uncertain costs.

Crucially, it also warned that the £20bn of public money set aside to develop CO2 capture is unlikely to be enough – and far more may be needed.

The findings pose a net zero nightmare for both Labour and Mr Miliband, who secured his position in cabinet amid a pledge to decarbonise Britain’s power system by 2030.

Under Labour’s green energy plans, carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies are being relied on to strip up to 30m tonnes of CO2 from UK emissions each year by 2030 – and more than 100m tonnes by 2050.

Given the unpredictability, the report warns that the focus on CCS by Mr Miliband’s Department of Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) could be misplaced.

Problems are so acute that DESNZ has even struggled to find people to work on its carbon capture programme, the NAO found, with more than 50 posts still unfilled.

It said: “DESNZ and the climate change committee have described CCS as being ‘essential’ to achieving net zero [but] the Government does not have and is currently not developing a credible alternative pathway without the use of CCS.

“DESNZ has applied lessons it has learnt from previous failed attempts to launch CCUS. But its inherently challenging nature remains, given the nascency of aspects of the technology.

“And DESNZ’s current approach brings new complexities to be managed, depending on parallel, interdependent negotiations with projects across different technologies.”

In practice, however, no-one has succeeded in developing a full-scale operating CCS system – partly because of engineering problems but also because of the huge costs.

Scientists estimate that capturing and burying the CO2 generated by a typical gas-fired power station could absorb 20pc of its energy production – making it uneconomic.

The NAO report warns: “There is a particular risk associated with the technology being unproven at the scale being planned, and with dependence on specialist expertise and equipment.

“For example, one of the UK emitter projects is planning to build a gas-fired power station with carbon capture, but this would be 40 times larger than any existing examples globally.

“A previous attempt to scale up CCS in the US ended before it started operating due to cost overruns attributed to the massive scaling up from pilot to commercial scale.

“Similarly, applications of CCS in the cement industry are unproven at scale, with potential limits to technical experience.”

Some experts back Mr Miliband’s determination. Simon Virley, head of energy and natural resources at KPMG’s UK accounting and consultancy division, said offshore wind had once looked unviable – but good engineering had made it a success story.

He believes the same can be achieved with carbon capture and storage.

“We have to make CCS work if we are to get to net zero and there is no time to waste,” he says.

“We have had two failed attempts before in the UK, so we must make it ‘third time lucky’, by learning lessons from past initiatives and through the Government being willing to de-risk early projects, through co-investment via the National Wealth Fund and GB Energy.”

Laith Whitwham, senior policy adviser for industrial transition and CCS at the climate think tank E3G, said previous ministers had to accept some blame for recent setbacks.

He said: “The new Government must balance the fact CCS is expensive with the fact it is needed to fully decarbonise some sectors. Frequent policy U-turns from the last government have not helped, slowing development and the scale-up that would have brought down costs.

“Nonetheless, there remains an economic opportunity, and the new Government should accelerate deployment where it makes sense.”

Scientists warn, however, that the technology still needs a great deal of research and engineering to succeed.

The Royal Society, the UK’s leading science organisation which has produced several reports on CCS, said: “An enormous and continued investment is needed each year to 2050 to build the injection wells, transport networks, monitoring technologies, and a skilled workforce, and to install hundreds of new wells each year.”

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2024/07/24/how-failure-carbon-capture-risks-net-zero-nightmare-labour

.

The suggestion that we must spend more than £20bn on something we don’t even know will work is preposterous. Let the US or EU waste their money instead. Yet fools like Whitwham and Virley still think we can make it work when the rest of the world has failed.

And even if there is a way to make CCS commercially viable, it will both massively increase the cost of electricity, as well as increase the consumption of natural gas, as CCS can use 20% of the power station’s energy production.

Gordon Hughes sums it up perfectly:

Some leading economists take an even tougher line. Among them is Gordon Hughes, emeritus professor of economics at Edinburgh University who spent much of his career working on energy issues for the World Bank.

He points out that in 2023 the UK generated about 100 terawatt hours of its electricity from gas – generating about 36m tonnes of CO2 – with no proven technology for capturing more than a fraction of that amount.

He said: “The target of capturing 20-30m tonnes of CO2 by 2030 is absurd and always has been.

“Over the next decade conventional carbon capture will be little more than an experimental technology. I don’t know what will happen in the 2040s and there is a small probability that CCS might be viable by then but the history of the last 15 years suggests that the chances are really very low.

“To be blunt, CCUS is like a lot of the plans for net zero – just a series of technically and economically illiterate fantasies designed to avoid the reality that reaching such a target is probably infeasible and is certainly ruinous for any modern industrial economy.”

Instead of wasting £20 billion on CCS research, it should be spent constructing a fleet of new CCGT plants. All further subsidies to wind and solar farms should be stopped and emission targets dropped.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/BnwKJ7k

July 25, 2024 at 04:02AM