Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Project 2025 on Energy (just a start, remember)

From MasterResource

By Robert Bradley Jr.

The Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025 covers federal energy policy in some detail. The agenda is largely free market, and the subtle politicization of means and ends under the Biden/Harris Administration is identified for reform.

This document is congruent with the very brief Republican Party energy platform, “Make America the Dominant Energy Producer in the World, by Far”. But it falls short of true classical liberalism, as exemplified by my general approach to free market energy; the call by the Cato Institute to “zero out” the U.S. Department of Energy (2011); and end all preferential energy taxation (in 2013); and IER’s American Energy Act (2011).

The energy sections of Project 2025 follow verbatim. I offer a final comment on some of the missing initiatives.

A conservative President must be committed to unleashing all of America’s energy resources and making the energy economy serve the American people, not special interests. This means that the next conservative Administration should:

  • Promote American energy security by ensuring access to abundant, reliable, and affordable energy.
  • Affirm an “all of the above” energy policy through which the best attributes of every resource can be harnessed for the benefit of the American people.
  • Support repeal of massive spending bills like the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) and Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), which established new programs and are providing hundreds of billions of dollars in subsidies to renewable energy developers, their investors, and special interests, and support the rescinding of all funds not already spent by these programs.
  • Unleash private-sector energy innovation by ending government interference in energy decisions.
  • Stop the war on oil and natural gas.
  • Allow individuals, families, and business to use the energy resources they want to use and that will best serve their needs.
  • Secure and protect energy infrastructure from cyber and physical attacks.
  • Refocus the Department of Energy on energy security, accelerated remediation, and advanced science.
  • Promote U.S. energy resources as a means to assist our allies and diminish our strategic adversaries
  • Refocus FERC on ensuring that customers have affordable and reliable electricity, natural gas, and oil and no longer allow it to favor special interests and progressive causes.
  • Ensure that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission facilitates rather than hampers private-sector nuclear energy innovation and deployment.

Mission Statement for a Reformed Department of Energy

  • The Department of Energy should be renamed and refocused as the Department of Energy Security and Advanced Science (DESAS). DESAS would refocus on DOE’s five existing core missions: Providing leadership and coordination on energy security and related national security issues,
  • Promoting U.S. energy economic interests abroad,
  • Leading the nation and the world in cutting-edge fundamental advanced science,
  • Remediating former Manhattan Project and Cold War nuclear material sites, and
  • Developing new nuclear weapons and naval nuclear reactors

Eliminate special-interest funding programs. Many DOE energy funding programs are not targeted on fundamental science and technology; instead, they focus more on commercialization and act as subsidies to the Department of Energy and Related Commissions private sector for government-favored resources. The DOE Office of Clean Energy Demonstrations (OCED); Office of State and Community Energy
Programs; ARPA-E; Office of Grid Deployment (OGD); and DOE Loan Program should be eliminated or reformed. If they continue to exist, FECM, NE, OE, and EERE should focus on fundamental science and technology issues, particularly in relation to cyber and physical threats to energy security, rather than subsidizing and commercializing energy resources.

Eliminate political and climate-change interference in DOE approvals of liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports. In addition, Congress should reform the Natural Gas Act to expand required approvals from
merely nations with free trade agreements to all of our allies, such as NATO countries.

Focus the Federal Energy Management Program (FEMP) on ensuring that government buildings and operations have reliable and cost-effective energy. FEMP should stop using taxpayer dollars to force the
purchase of more expensive and less reliable energy resources in the name of combating climate change.

Ensure that information provided by the U.S. Energy Information Agency (EIA), a data and statistical organization, is data-neutral.

Focus FERC on its statutory obligation to ensure access to reliable energy at just, reasonable, and nondiscriminatory rates. FERC is a five-member commission created under the DOE Organization Act that
regulates the wholesale sales and transmission of electricity, promotes electric reliability through standards, permits natural gas pipelines and LNG export facilities, sets natural gas pipeline shipping rates, and sets oil pipeline shipping rates. It is an economic regulator and should not make itself a climate regulator.

Streamline the nuclear regulatory requirements and licensing process. Such changes would help to lower costs and accelerate the development and deployment of civilian nuclear, such as advanced nuclear reactors (including small modular nuclear reactors). The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is commission tasked with the licensing of civilian nuclear reactors and power plants and regulating other uses of nuclear materials, such as nuclear medicine. Although it is not a DOE agency, its jurisdiction over nuclear reactor, fuel, safety, and trade issues often relates to or impinges on DOE’s jurisdiction.

Focus on energy and science issues, not politicized social programs.

The next Administration should stop using energy policy to advance politicized social agendas. Programs that sound innocuous, such as “energy justice,” Justice40, and DEI, can be transformed to promote politicized agendas. DOE should focus on providing all Americans with access to abundant, affordable, reliable, and secure energy, and DOE should manage its employees so that everyone is treated fairly based on his or her talent, skills, and hard work.

Analysis

A better, more thorough-going free market energy agenda would correct or add the following:

  • Replace “‘all of the above’ energy policy” with consumer-driven, taxpayer-neutral “energy policy, through which the best attributes of every resource can be harnessed for the benefit of the American people.”
  • Eliminate the civilian programs of the U.S. Department of Energy rather than “Refocus [DOE] … on energy security, accelerated remediation, and advanced science.”
  • End all government subsidies to nuclear power.
  • Abolish the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) rather than reform it, which would require repealing enabling legislation such as the Federal Power Act of 1935 and Natural Gas Act of 1938.
  • Privatize the energy assets of the Department of Energy, the Department of Interior, and other energy agencies,

Numerous other federal laws should be repealed, including the Public Utility Holding Company Act of 1935, Public Utility Regulatory Practices Act of 1978, and the Energy Policy Act (various years).

———–

[1] The Cato Institute’s Handbook for Policymakers does not include a chapter on energy, and it ducks the whole issue of climate change in the environmental chapter. Peter van Doren is the culprit here.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/crMvKPU

July 24, 2024 at 08:03AM

How the failure of carbon capture risks causing a net zero nightmare

By Paul Homewood

.

h/t Philip Bratby

.

Meanwhile Miliband’s plans to rely on carbon capture are in ruins:

 

 

image

Ed Miliband has promised to drastically speed up Britain’s net zero transition but the scale of the task facing the Energy Secretary was laid bare in a damning report from the National Audit Office (NAO), published on Tuesday.

Officials told the Energy Secretary that a staggering £630m of taxpayer cash has been spent on carbon capture technology that is still years from working.

Not only did they point to the amount of investment at risk, but also stressed that the Government’s overarching goal to capture up to 30m tonnes of CO2 by 2030 is way off track.

Driving this underperformance is the fact that four key carbon capture projects are already years behind schedule, the NAO said, which is without recognising the untested technology and uncertain costs.

Crucially, it also warned that the £20bn of public money set aside to develop CO2 capture is unlikely to be enough – and far more may be needed.

The findings pose a net zero nightmare for both Labour and Mr Miliband, who secured his position in cabinet amid a pledge to decarbonise Britain’s power system by 2030.

Under Labour’s green energy plans, carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies are being relied on to strip up to 30m tonnes of CO2 from UK emissions each year by 2030 – and more than 100m tonnes by 2050.

Given the unpredictability, the report warns that the focus on CCS by Mr Miliband’s Department of Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) could be misplaced.

Problems are so acute that DESNZ has even struggled to find people to work on its carbon capture programme, the NAO found, with more than 50 posts still unfilled.

It said: “DESNZ and the climate change committee have described CCS as being ‘essential’ to achieving net zero [but] the Government does not have and is currently not developing a credible alternative pathway without the use of CCS.

“DESNZ has applied lessons it has learnt from previous failed attempts to launch CCUS. But its inherently challenging nature remains, given the nascency of aspects of the technology.

“And DESNZ’s current approach brings new complexities to be managed, depending on parallel, interdependent negotiations with projects across different technologies.”

In practice, however, no-one has succeeded in developing a full-scale operating CCS system – partly because of engineering problems but also because of the huge costs.

Scientists estimate that capturing and burying the CO2 generated by a typical gas-fired power station could absorb 20pc of its energy production – making it uneconomic.

The NAO report warns: “There is a particular risk associated with the technology being unproven at the scale being planned, and with dependence on specialist expertise and equipment.

“For example, one of the UK emitter projects is planning to build a gas-fired power station with carbon capture, but this would be 40 times larger than any existing examples globally.

“A previous attempt to scale up CCS in the US ended before it started operating due to cost overruns attributed to the massive scaling up from pilot to commercial scale.

“Similarly, applications of CCS in the cement industry are unproven at scale, with potential limits to technical experience.”

Some experts back Mr Miliband’s determination. Simon Virley, head of energy and natural resources at KPMG’s UK accounting and consultancy division, said offshore wind had once looked unviable – but good engineering had made it a success story.

He believes the same can be achieved with carbon capture and storage.

“We have to make CCS work if we are to get to net zero and there is no time to waste,” he says.

“We have had two failed attempts before in the UK, so we must make it ‘third time lucky’, by learning lessons from past initiatives and through the Government being willing to de-risk early projects, through co-investment via the National Wealth Fund and GB Energy.”

Laith Whitwham, senior policy adviser for industrial transition and CCS at the climate think tank E3G, said previous ministers had to accept some blame for recent setbacks.

He said: “The new Government must balance the fact CCS is expensive with the fact it is needed to fully decarbonise some sectors. Frequent policy U-turns from the last government have not helped, slowing development and the scale-up that would have brought down costs.

“Nonetheless, there remains an economic opportunity, and the new Government should accelerate deployment where it makes sense.”

Scientists warn, however, that the technology still needs a great deal of research and engineering to succeed.

The Royal Society, the UK’s leading science organisation which has produced several reports on CCS, said: “An enormous and continued investment is needed each year to 2050 to build the injection wells, transport networks, monitoring technologies, and a skilled workforce, and to install hundreds of new wells each year.”

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2024/07/24/how-failure-carbon-capture-risks-net-zero-nightmare-labour/

.

The suggestion that we must spend more than £20bn on something we don’t even know will work is preposterous. Let the US or EU waste their money instead. Yet fools like Whitwham and Virley still think we can make it work when the rest of the world has failed.

And even if there is a way to make CCS commercially viable, it will both massively increase the cost of electricity, as well as increase the consumption of natural gas, as CCS can use 20% of the power station’s energy production.

Gordon Hughes sums it up perfectly:

 

Some leading economists take an even tougher line. Among them is Gordon Hughes, emeritus professor of economics at Edinburgh University who spent much of his career working on energy issues for the World Bank.

He points out that in 2023 the UK generated about 100 terawatt hours of its electricity from gas – generating about 36m tonnes of CO2 – with no proven technology for capturing more than a fraction of that amount.

He said: “The target of capturing 20-30m tonnes of CO2 by 2030 is absurd and always has been.

“Over the next decade conventional carbon capture will be little more than an experimental technology. I don’t know what will happen in the 2040s and there is a small probability that CCS might be viable by then but the history of the last 15 years suggests that the chances are really very low.

“To be blunt, CCUS is like a lot of the plans for net zero – just a series of technically and economically illiterate fantasies designed to avoid the reality that reaching such a target is probably infeasible and is certainly ruinous for any modern industrial economy.”

Instead of wasting £20 billion on CCS research, it should be spent constructing a fleet of new CCGT plants. All further subsidies to wind and solar farms should be stopped and emission targets dropped.

via NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

https://ift.tt/OvlS2jP

July 24, 2024 at 07:39AM

UK may need new gas-fired power stations to decarbonise grid–Guardian

By Paul Homewood

h/t Ian Magness

.

When even the Guardian recognises we will still need gas power stations for many years to come, you know Miliband’s plans are pie in the sky:

.

 

  image

Labour is likely to have to approve new gas-fired power stations in its attempt to decarbonise the UK’s electricity systems by 2030, in what would be a tricky decision for the new government.

Keeping the lights on for the rest of the decade, and beyond, will require some additional baseload power, and new nuclear power stations will not be built in time, according to a report from the National Engineering Policy Centre.

All the UK’s existing gas-fired power stations are expected to be kept going as long as possible but it is probable that more will be needed. Wind and solar generation are set for large increases but the UK’s nuclear reactors are ageing and coal has almost been phased out.

Nilay Shah, a professor of process systems engineering at Imperial College London and a co-author of the report, said: “There is a reasonable chance that we will need new gas-fired power stations.”

However he called for them to be “genuinely” ready for the attachment of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology, which could be achieved by locating them near potential underground carbon storage sites. He said the number needed would depend on factors such as building new interconnectors between the UK and overseas electricity grids.

Simon Harrison, the head of strategy at the engineering company Mott MacDonald who co-chaired the committee that wrote the report, added that having a small number of gas-fired power stations available would add to the UK’s resilience, even if they did produce some carbon emissions. “We have to not be purist about unabated gas,” he said.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/article/2024/jul/23/uk-may-need-new-gas-fired-power-stations-to-decarbonise-grid

 

Although the report calls for new power stations to be CCS ready, that does not mean they will have CCS fitted. And they will need to be built now, not in ten years time.

Add in the existing gas plants that will be kept going as long as possible, and it is now dawning even on the Guardian that we Miliband cannot decarbonise the grid by 2030 as he promised.

via NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

https://ift.tt/Mrivekl

July 24, 2024 at 07:18AM

1-Minute Junking: July 21, 2024 was the ‘hottest day ever’?

Related links: Reuters article | Copernicus report | Temperature.global UPDATE: Just in… Temperature.global confirms my video: Climate hoaxers claim July 21, 2024 was the ‘hottest day ever’ at 62.76°F (17.09°C). But the average of surface station measurments on that day was actually 56.96°F (13.87°C) almost 6°F cooler.

via JunkScience.com

https://ift.tt/dOGNEn0

July 24, 2024 at 05:28AM