Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

SCARE TACTICS EXPOSED AS MERELY HOT AIR

Jo Nova’s excellent blog is constantly reminding us of how ridiculous the dramatic headlines are which reference some new climate record. When you see what is going on with the temperature measurements from our Met Office (see previous days posts) you realise what nonsense all this talk is. Read her latest post to understand what is really happening.  

 Sunday was 0.01 degree hotter than last year, and 1 or 2 degrees cooler than what cavemen lived through. So What? « JoNova (joannenova.com.au)

It is quite possible to accept that CO2 is causing some warming while still being sceptical of whether that warming is a serious threat as opposed to merely one factor among many which can lead to changes in our climate. What we need to do is recognise that many of the factors affecting the climate are beyond our control. We need to learn to adapt and mitigate the most extreme weather and stop trying to control it.

via climate science

https://ift.tt/EPCQfpG

July 24, 2024 at 01:31AM

Nuclear Fusion: More Government Fail

“The fusion propaganda machine has produced a wave of mostly offbeat projects, more than 40 since 2018 by one estimate. The likelihood that any of these fusion pipedreams will produce anything other than red ink is less than slim.”

Harsh reality is again clashing with the fanciful hype of the past several years regarding fusion energy. The only credible attempt to harness the physics of the sun, the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor, has again pushed back the date when it will attempt a sustained fusion reaction toward practical energy production.

For the second time in two years, the 35-nation project has announced a snag in the project, although it has reported some better news. At a July 3 press conference at ITER headquarters in France, Director-General Pietro Barabaschi said the new goal is to be able to run the toroidal magnets in the donut-shaped tokomak briefly at full power in 2036. The deuterium-tritium operation phase, where the fusion rubber really begins to meet the road, won’t occur before 2039.

The new timeline will add some $5 billion to the current approximately $20 billion+ cost estimate for the pilot project. Exact costs are difficult to calculate as much of the support comes from in-kind contributions from the 35 member countries: China, the European Union, India, Japan, Russia, South Korea and the United States. The United Kingdom participates through EU‘s Fusion for Energy (F4E), Switzerland participates through Euratom and F4E, and the project has cooperation agreements with Australia, Canada, Kazakhstan and Thailand. Europe provides about 45% of the ITER funding.

What does this mean in terms of the many promises of fusion energy? In surprising candor, Barabaschi said,

“Fusion cannot arrive in time to solve the problems our planet faces today, and investment in other technologies, known and unknown, is absolutely needed. But I expect fusion will make a difference when it arrives, and let’s not forget that there is not just the problem of solving global warming … energy is also needed for life on Earth.”

Science magazine added a caveat to that announcement. ITER’s tokomak machine will run in 2039 “only in short bursts, to satisfy safety concerns of the nuclear regulator in France, where ITER is under construction.” Even if ITER is a complete success, that’s only a first, albeit big, step. It will not generate electricity. That requires solving the gigantic problem of building a plant to convert the energy to electric power.

Barabaschi is far more open than his predecessor, Bernard Bigot, who was fond of fusion enthusiasm and downplayed the problems that have plagued the project throughout its life. Michel Claessens, who was ITER’s communications chief until Bigot fired him upon taking office in 2015, told Science|Business this year that too many fusion researchers and officials have become purveyors of what he terms “fusion propaganda.” Claessens said,

We should be clear with the public. We are still in the research and development phase. We’re still far from commercial applications. I’m really upset, and I don’t think it helps, when people say fusion will be the energy of the future.

The good news is that in April, ITER took delivery of the first of 19 giant toroidal magnets that are the heart of the magnetic confinement tokomak, prompting a July 1 celebration. All 19 of the coils (18 for the machine and one spare, 10 from Europe and 9 from Japan) are due to ITER’s southern France headquarters in Saint-Paul-lès-Durance in three-and-a-half years.

Barabaschi commented that the 17-meter-tall coils “look like science-fiction.” They are 40-times the mass of the magnets at the European nuclear research laboratory CERN, the largest operating magnets in the world today.

A Look Back

ITER had its beginning in 1978 as a modest proposal for an international program to develop a Tokomak fusion project. The project moved forward with little attention beyond technical circles, until it burst upon the public scene during the 1985 Geneva summit between U.S. President Ronald Reagan and Soviet Union General Secretary Mikhail Gorbachev.

In Geneva, the two major world leaders agreed to cooperate on fusion R&D, issuing a statement that “the potential importance of the work aimed at utilizing controlled thermonuclear fusion for peaceful purposes and, in this connection, advocated the widest practicable development of international cooperation in obtaining this source of energy, which is essentially inexhaustible, for the benefit of all mankind.” Reagan touted the collaboration in a joint session of the U.S. Congress.

The U.S. then had an on-again, off-again relationship with the project as it began to put together what became ITER. The U.S. pulled out of the planning in 1998, complaining that the projected $10 billion cost was excessive. When the planners scaled back to effort to $5 billion in 2002, the U.S. rejoined. The original funding was $6 billion, with a 10-year time frame.

Many Hurdles

What are the major obstacles that practical fusion must overcome? Claessens outlines the most significant: “The question of economic sustainability is so open today because these machines are very expensive.”

Tritium. This extremely rare hydrogen isotope is crucial. Fusion optimists are counting on “tritium breeding” to overcome this fundamental problem. The concept is that the fusion machine will create more tritium than it uses. Claessens comments, “It is at least a question mark.”

Economics. The fusion hype artists talk glowingly about “virtually limitless energy,” as if hydrogen is a free fuel. Even if uranium were free, electricity from nuclear fission plants would still be expensive. Claessens: “The question of economic sustainability is so open today because these machines are very expensive.”

Materials. The fusion reaction will involve enormous temperatures, perhaps exceeding those in the sun. Finding materials that can hold these hot plasmas is far from solved. The process will also produce copious neutrons that will irradiate everything in their path. There will be no spent fuel from fusion. There will be plenty of radioactive materials.

Conclusion

Unlike his predecessors, Barabaschi has not tried to paper over fusion’s problem. ITER communications chief Laban Coblentz, who took over upon the firing of Claessens, has said, “With Pietro’s arrival at ITER, there’s been a deliberate effort to look at how we communicate about fusion that is factual, avoids overpromising, and tries to address questions that fusion sceptics have in a fair and realistic way.”

Despite that, the fusion propaganda machine has produced a wave of mostly offbeat projects, more than 40 since 2018 by one estimate. The likelihood that any of these fusion pipedreams will produce anything other than red ink is less than slim.

The post Nuclear Fusion: More Government Fail appeared first on Master Resource.

via Master Resource

https://ift.tt/d7SpYo2

July 24, 2024 at 01:06AM

Natural Gas Industry’s Smear of Coal Is False and Self-Defeating

By Gregory Wrightstone

Smearing coal has become a marketing strategy of a natural gas industry that embraces pseudoscientific views of coal combustion as being hazardous.

In so doing, gas supporters give credence to a fallacious regulatory regime of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), which erroneously classifies carbon dioxide as a pollutant and assigns health effects to low-level pollution without scientific proof. To boot, a false representation of coal, oil and natural gas as environmental bogeymen is perpetuated.

Perhaps the most enthusiastic user of this foolish ploy is Toby Rice, CEO of Pittsburgh-based EQT Corp., who introduced two years ago a global plan to replace coal with liquefied natural gas. Promoting his product as a “decarbonizing force” in June at a RealClearEnergy conference, the head of the country’s largest gas producer (check the video link above to see his part), said:

“What we would like to do at EQT … is focus people on a really practical solution that will allow us to provide energy security for the world and address people’s concerns over global emissions. And that path is very simple: transition the world from coal to gas.”

Although natural gas emits less carbon dioxide than coal when burned, the underlying premise of Rice’s pitch rests on the popular myth that CO2 emissions will overheat the planet. The organization we lead, the CO2 Coalition, has overwhelming evidence from top scientists showing that increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide not only poses no danger but is beneficial to plant growth and crop production.

We need more CO2 not less. Coal miners could say that replacing their product with gas is a threat to greenery.

Now, the gas industry’s Marcellus Shale Coalition has further demonized coal in claiming that Pennsylvanians have realized up to $1 trillion in health benefits by reducing emissions of nitrogen and sulfur compounds through the replacement coal-fired electricity generation with gas-fueled power plants.

We have no quarrel with the emissions data. However, the link to improved health is based on methodologies of an EPA that has refused for decades to provide evidence for such a connection.

EPA has long trafficked in data manipulation and falsehood about the supposed health effects of particulate matter, which would be the carrier of chemical compounds into people’s lungs, according to Steve Milloy, publisher of JunkScience.com and author of “Scare Pollution: Why and how to fix the EPA.”

“The bottom line is that the claim that particulate matter causes death is the most demonstrable science fraud of our time,” says Milloy, a lawyer with a master’s degree in health sciences and biostatistics. “Despite fearmongering for 30 years about millions of deaths, EPA — and nobody else — has ever presented a single dead body.”

Since the 1990s, Milloy has sparred with the EPA over its assertion that particulate matter measuring 2.5 microns or less (PM2.5) is life threatening. PM2.5 was identified as a dangerous pollutant by EPA’s environmental extremists to shut down the coal industry, he says.

While insisting that PM2.5 kills 8 million people annually, says Milloy, EPA has ignored a contradictory epidemiological study by California researchers as well as the results of its own experiments, which failed to produce symptoms in human subjects intentionally exposed to high levels of particulates.

In 1995, the agency’s own Clean Air Scientific Advisory Council rejected EPA findings of health effects from PM2.5 and was denied raw data to examine the claims. EPA also refused to give the data to congressional investigators.

The absence of support for EPA’s regulation of PM2.5 should not be a surprise. In a 2023 study, Dr. Indur Goklany found that mortality and disease rates improved over a 27-year period even as industrialization and particulate emissions increased in five Asian countries:  India, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal and China.

The gas industry jumps on the bandwagon of demonizing coal to gain the acceptance of the “green” lobby and the politicians who pander to it. However, gas producers are only feeding coal miners to the crocodile that they hope to escape. It’s a fool’s game, as should be evident by the environmental extremists’ regular targeting of gas operations.

A better approach would be for gas and coal interests to stand together for their industries and the immense good that hydrocarbons have done for the world since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, when coal first fueled steam engines. An alliance of drillers and miners could help defeat a vicious anti-science ideology that seeks to destroy their livelihoods and the civilization they have made possible.

This commentary was first published at Real Clear Energy on July 22, 2024.

Gregory Wrightstone is a geologist; executive director of the CO2 Coalition, Arlington, Va.; author of Inconvenient Facts: The Science That Al Gore Doesn’t Want You to Know and A Very Convenient Warming: How modest warming and more CO2 are benefiting humanity.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/F3Wx06n

July 24, 2024 at 12:08AM

Watch: VP Kamala Harris supports bans on plastic straws & offshore drilling – Changes to dietary guidelines to battle ‘climate change, & seeks ‘to get rid of the filibuster to pass a Green New Deal’

From CLIMATE DEPOT

By Marc Morano

Related:

Joe Bastardi’s Point-by-point rebuttal of Kamala Harris’s unscientific climate tweet

Watch: Likely Dem Prez Nominee Kamala Harris says she would force millions of workers in the energy sector to ‘transition’ to new jobs — such as ‘installation of wind turbines and solar paneling’

Flashback 2021: Kamala’s ‘evidence-free empty rhetoric’: Watch: Morano on Tucker Carlson talks VP Kamala Harris blaming immigration on ‘climate change’

Kamala Harris Defends the Green New Deal and Wants a ’New President’ So ‘We Can Change Human Behaviors’ on Climate Change

Kamala Harris laughs about paper straws quickly collapsing, but still wants to ban plastic straws

COVID lockdowns to morph into climate lockdowns: Biden’s VP pick Kamala Harris seeks Green New Deal so ‘we can change human behaviors’

Kamala’s Nutty Green Vision: Ban Plastic Straws, Limit Red Meat

VP nominee Kamala Harris has a particular climate-change agenda: environmental justice

Kamala Harris Defends the Green New Deal and Wants a ’New President’ So ‘We Can Change Human Behaviors’ on Climate Change

Kamala Harris is PRANKED by Russian hoaxers who pose as climate activist Greta Thunberg and her father and offer Biden’s VP pick ‘dirt’ on Trump

Flashback: Kamala Harris sued Obama-Biden over fracking

Like Biden, Kamala Harris Has Endorsed A Complete Fracking Ban – Harris: ‘There is no question I’m in favor of banning fracking’

Kamala Harris Flip-Flops on Fracking After Polls Tighten in Pennsylvania

VP nominee Kamala Harris asks about smoking/cancer & climate change in Q&A with Amy Coney Barrett

Kamala Harris Tells Unemployed Coal Miners That After Biden Kills Their Jobs They Should Work Reclaiming Abandoned ‘Land Mines’

https://ift.tt/iHEzhJU By Cristina Laila “Land Mines” Joe Biden killed tens of thousands of jobs his first day in office when he canceled contracts with the Keystone XL pipeline. Biden and his “Climate Envoy” John Kerry are waging war on the energy sector but fear not because Kamala Harris is here to save the day. TRENDING: Perfect. […]Media Puff Piece: Fighting Climate Change Could Define Kamala Harris’ Vice Presidency

VP Kamala Harris announces new $3 billion US pledge to ‘global climate action’ at UN Dubai summit to help developing nations ‘cut fossil fuel pollution’

https://ift.tt/sKAJOZt By Kyle Feldscher and Ella Nilsen, CNN CNN — Vice President Kamala Harris announced new funding for climate action on Saturday at the COP28 summit in Dubai, where she touted American leadership on the climate crisis, including its recent investments in clean energy and efforts to make vulnerable communities more resilient to worsening climate disasters. Harris said the US would […]

KAMALA HARRIS misspeaks?!: ‘When we invest in clean energy & electric vehicles & REDUCE POPULATION, more of our children can breath clean air & drink clean water’

KAMALA HARRIS: “When we invest in clean energy and electric vehicles and reduce population, more of our children can breath clean air and drink clean water.” pic.twitter.com/MbMiDx9Xoc — RNC Research (@RNCResearch) July 14, 2023 Kamala Harris mistakenly proposes reducing population instead of pollution – In a verbal slip-up, Harris spoke of reducing ‘population’ to breathe […]

VP Kamala Harris urges youth organizing to fight ‘climate anxiety’ – ‘You have endured a mental & emotional toll of this crisis’

https://ift.tt/SjTzJ9a By SETH KLAMANN Linking the climate crisis to youth-driven political movements of the past, Vice President Kamala Harris spoke at a Denver high school Friday and urged students to organize and fight to change the hotter, dryer world they’re inheriting. “You have endured a mental and emotional toll of this crisis,” she said at Denver’s […]Kamala Harris issues dire climate warning in Africa: ‘Existential threat to the entire planet’ – Praises Zambian farm for climate-friendly agriculture practices

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/NPe3cq8

July 23, 2024 at 08:07PM