Children’s Climate Court Case Pushing an Injunction Against Fossil Fuel Extraction

Some of the kids being used as climate pawns. Photo:

Guest essay by Eric Worrall

The Ninth Circuit is currently hearing an attempt by the Juliana v. United States plaintiffs to halt all fossil fuel extraction in the United States.

The kids suing the government over climate change want to halt fossil fuel extraction

The plaintiffs in Juliana v. United States say they’ve been denied their right to a safe and stable climate.

Umair Irfan

If the injunction is granted, it would lead to a nationwide moratorium on new fossil fuel permitting and leasing on federal lands and waters until the lawsuit is resolved. No small matter. However, existing mining and drilling projects would still proceed.

Philip Gregory, one of the lead attorneys representing the children filing suit, explained that the injunction request is meant to address the urgency of limiting climate change by reducing emissions from fossil fuels immediately. With the case currently tied up in appeals, the plaintiffs wanted to make sure the current state of affairs with respect to climate change doesn’t get worse as the wheels of justice slowly turn.

“We would have preferred to go to trial, submit our extensive evidence, and have the judge require the defendants to come up with a plan, a national climate recovery plan, for how they’re going to go about doing this,” Gregory said.

In response, the federal government argued this week that the injunction maneuver is a ploy to bypass proper legal proceedings. “Indeed, Plaintiffs by their present motion are essentially making a bid in this Court for a substitute mini-trial or ‘trial lite’ — which is premature until the pure issues of law now being briefed in this interlocutory appeal are appropriately resolved as a threshold matter,” wrote attorneys for the US Department of Justice. They described the injunction request as an “ambitious attempt to throttle important government functions superintending broad swaths of the national economy.”

The government also noted that the Juliana lawsuit was filed more than three years ago but the plaintiffs hadn’t asked to block fossil fuel leasing until now, which undermines the plaintiffs’ argument that without immediate action, they would suffer irreparable harm.

Read more:

A copy of the injunction is available here.

Even President Obama did not support this case – when James Hansen urged Obama to tie President Trump’s hands on climate policy. by settling the case in the plaintiff’s favour, President Obama refused.

I feel sorry for the kids, whom I see as victims of callous green political manipulation. This court case will almost certainly eventually be tossed out, and those poor kids will likely have to live with the crushing disappointment of being tossed aside by their former green friends once they are no longer any immediate use to the green movement.

via Watts Up With That?

February 23, 2019 at 10:07PM

2 thoughts on “Children’s Climate Court Case Pushing an Injunction Against Fossil Fuel Extraction”

  1. I couldn’t even be bothered reading that fucking crock if shit she never filed or requested any legal action in the first place in fact the action taken came as a surprise to her and in fact embarrassed her more then anything and she did as well as her mother request it to be withdrawn and not put through any court system. The fact of the matter is the writing could only have been both placed there and interpretated by climate change authors as it was illegible to anyone else so that in itself was a iframe and this has been admitted by climate change previously. So that story and any damage done by any further or previous will in fact fuel more reason for both deeper and more investigatiive behaviours of climate change authorities so start paying up and do so immediately. Remember what coin you are holding was brought by me intially and I spent years and went through many avenues trying to recover it and was blocked at every road so this is further damination of the climate change authority let Aline both the punitive and physical and psychological damages they caused in large and various degrees 

    Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s