Harrabin’s Anti Coal Mine Campaign

By Paul Homewood




 Proposed Woodhouse Colliery – Artist’s Impression


The case for the proposed new coal mine in Cumbria really should be a no-brainer for most sensible people. The state of the art mine will extract and process 3.1 million tonnes a year of high grade coking coal, for use in steelworks in the UK and Europe, which currently have to import it from the US and Russia.

The mine is designed to be a clean operation with very little environmental impact, with the coal transferred by underground conveyer to the local rail depot, where it can be shipped to customers. There will be no road freight of coal at all, and all waste will be buried underground.

The project will create 500 direct jobs, plus many more in supply chains. Unsurprisingly the local council have given full approval to go ahead.

However the government’s recent decision not to block it on environmental grounds has infuriated extreme environmental groups such as Greenpeace. And leading the charge is the BBC’s Roger Harrabin, who is improperly using his role as the BBC’s Environmental Analyst to actively campaign against the new colliery.

His latest BBC report, “Climate change: Boris Johnson ‘risks humiliation’ over coal mine”, is wholly devoted to a letter to the Prime Minister from James Hansen, the US climate scientist and extreme environmental activist, who was once arrested at a protest. Naturally, Hansen wants the mine banned, though quite what relevance the views of one US activist has to do with the democratic process in this country defeats me.

In common with most Harrabin articles, this one fails to offer any counter views of those in favour. It follows other articles in the last month, such as “Climate change: Six questions about the Cumbria coal controversy”, “Government defends Cumbria coal mine green light” and “Climate change: Minister rapped for allowing Cumbria coal mine”.

All are heavily slanted to the views of Greenpeace and other extreme environmental groups, while virtually nothing is reported about the substantial benefits the mine will bring. In particular, Harrabin consistently fails to publish the views of the local council, community or West Cumbria Mining who are developing the mine.

It is abundantly clear that Harrabin is abusing his position at the BBC to politically campaign against the mine. If he wants to be an environmental campaigner, fine. But he cannot do that and be a BBC employee at the same time.



February 5, 2021 at 12:31PM

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s