Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Countering the climate exaggerators squatting in the house of weather

This was the Wetherbell.com Summer forecast, and when August is done, its going to be pretty darn close. Here are the opening bullet points: Heat is expected to build over the Rockies. A ridge will expand over the West, leaving a weakness in the Southeast and back toward the southern Plains. Hurricane season should grow […]

via CFACT

https://ift.tt/TsSLZu8

July 31, 2024 at 11:24PM

Air New Zealand scraps its 2030 carbon emissions target, saying solutions are costly and scarce

From NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

By Paul Homewood

From the Independent:

Air New Zealand scrapped its 2030 carbon emissions reduction targets on Tuesday, citing lags in producing new planes, a lack of alternative fuel and “challenging” regulatory and policy settings.

The move by the national carrier — one of New Zealand’s biggest companies by revenue — was the highest-profile reversal yet of an airline’s commitments to a U.N. framework for corporations to stay on track to meet the Paris Agreement on emissions reductions, highlighting the hurdles facing carriers and policymakers in cutting aviation emissions.

“If even Air New Zealand can’t do it, it kind of cements the reality that reducing emissions from aviation is an impossible task under the current technical regime,” said James Higham, a sustainable tourism expert at Griffith University in Australia.

Tuesday’s update was a sharp turnaround from a 2022 announcement by Air New Zealand in which it declared itself the second carrier in the world to have its plans validated by the U.N.’s Science Based Targets Initiative aviation framework. It pledged a 28.9% reduction in carbon emissions 2030, from a 2019 baseline, with a 16.3% drop in absolute emissions.

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world/air-new-zealand-scraps-its-2030-carbon-emissions-target-saying-solutions-are-costly-and-scarce/ar-BB1qTkXY

Bit by bit, Net Zero ambitions are coming up against the wall of reality.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/IZN59tK

July 31, 2024 at 08:06PM

No Governor Inslee, Repeal of Washington State’s Climate Commitment Act Won’t Hurt the Climate

By Steve Goreham

Originally published in Master Resource.

Washington State’s Climate Commitment Act (CCA) faces the possibility of repeal this fall. Governor Jay Inslee and others claim the CCA will reduce pollution and help stop climate change. But the CCA isn’t having the slightest effect on the climate, while it is boosting the cost of living for Washington residents.

Washington’s Climate Commitment Act passed in 2021, implementing a cap and invest program designed to reduce state greenhouse gas emissions by 95% by 2050. Businesses with emissions of 25,000 tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) per year must purchase allowances equal to their emissions and turn them in to state agencies. The act also established CO2 auctions, encouraging companies to trade allowances and reduce emissions.

But the CCA has helped to raise Washington State’s cost of living to amongst the highest in the nation. Gasoline and diesel prices now rank as the third highest behind Hawaii and California. The cost of emissions allowances to businesses drives up fuel, food, and utility prices for residents.

On January 16 of this year, the Washington Secretary of State certified Initiative 2117 for the ballot on November 5, 2024, having received more than 400,000 supporting signatures. Initiative 2117 would repeal the Climate Commitment Act and prevent the state from implementing cap and trade or cap and tax carbon trading programs. Governor Inslee is concerned that his signature climate change program may be struck down by the people.

When speaking in Spokane recently in defense of the Climate Commitment Act, Governor Inslee said, “ … families in Washington State are against pollution. They are against smoke coming into their neighborhoods where they can’t go out, their kids can’t go out and play. They’re against early death caused by pollution and they don’t want to remove our protection against pollution.”

However, the governor’s statements are wrong. The Climate Commitment Act strives to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, primarily carbon dioxide. But carbon dioxide is an odorless, invisible gas that does not produce smoke. Nor does breathing of CO2 cause early death.

We inhale only a trace of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, but continuously produce CO2 as we burn sugars in our bodies. Every time we exhale, we exhale 100 times the concentration of the CO2 that we inhaled. The governor is mistakenly talking about the effects of breathing in real pollutants such as carbon monoxide or smoke particles, which can cause people harm, and instead wrongly attributes harmful health effects to carbon dioxide.

In fact, carbon dioxide should not be called a pollutant. Along with water and oxygen, CO2 is one of the three substances essential for life. Hundreds of peer-reviewed papers show that higher levels of atmospheric CO2 help the world’s food crops grow bigger and yield more food. Carbon dioxide is one compound we can put into the environment that is great for the biosphere.

The human emissions of carbon dioxide from Washington are estimated to be about 100 million metric tons per year. World CO2 human emissions are estimated at 37,000 million metric tons per year. This means that global emissions are 370 times as large as the emissions from Washington State.

In addition, human emissions of CO2 are small compared to the CO2 naturally exhausted from oceans and the biosphere. Every day, nature puts about twenty times as much carbon dioxide into the atmosphere as human industry and removes about the same amount. Washington emissions are less than insignificant as part Earth’s climate. The Climate Commitment Act will have a negligible effect on the climate, but if not repealed, it will continue to significantly raise fuel, food, and utility prices in Washington.

Why is it that climate policies never have a measurable goal? None of our leaders can say that a given policy will reduce temperatures by so many degrees, or reduce sea level rise by so many inches, or reduce the number of storms by a tangible amount, even if added to other policies. Fighting climate change is like raising an army and never taking a hill or building a hospital and never serving a patient. Yet more and more money must be endlessly spent to serve the ideology of Climatism.

This fall, the citizens of Washington State should reject Climatism and vote in favor of the resolution to strike down the Climate Commitment Act.

Steve Goreham is a speaker on energy, the environment, and public policy and the author of the bestselling book Green Breakdown: The Coming Renewable Energy Failure.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/TnJQLct

July 31, 2024 at 04:05PM

What Australia could learn from China (or maybe not)

This ABC Sceince article is making the claim that “China is installing the wind and solar equivalent of five large nuclear power stations per week”. That drew my attention because there obviously is no solar and wind “equivalent” to nuclear (one is intermittent and the other dispatchable, therefore having a very different capacity factor) and I think that the comparison between the two countries is also flawed.

The article portrayed China as some kind of guide country on the installation of new renewable capacity and the gist of the article is that Australia should learn from China and follow in its footsteps. Some of the claims being made:

  • China is installing record amounts of solar and wind, while scaling back once-ambitious plans for nuclear
  • China may meet its end-of-2030 target by the end of this month, while Australia is falling behind its renewables installation targets
  • Energy experts are looking to China (the world’s largest emitter and once a climate villain) for lessons on how to rapidly decarbonize
  • They’re installing 1GW per month of pumped hydro storage, while Australia is struggling to build the 2GW Snowy 2.0 in 10 years
  • A recent drop in emissions (the first since relaxing COVID-19 restrictions), combined with the decarbonisation of the power grid, may mean the country’s emissions have peaked.

It is a long time that I looked into the China energy data, so I wondered how those numbers evolved and how both countries would compare when I put them next to each other. I would be surprised when China would come out better.

Let’s first start with the numbers. China installs 10 GW of solar and wind capacity every two weeks, that is 5 GW per week as mentioned in the title of the article. This solar and wind capacity of 5 GW equates to a capacity of five nuclear power plants of 1 GW. That is what this “five large nuclear power stations per week” comes from.

That is misleading because solar and wind are intermittent while nuclear is dispatchable and therefore have a different capacity factor. To the credit of ABC Science, they acknowledged this in the article (although they buried this clarification much further in the article). There, they explain what a capacity factor is and state that renewables have a capacity factor of about 25% while the capacity factor of nuclear can be as high as 90%, therefore the output of this “equivalent” of 5 nuclear plants would be closer to that of just 1 large nuclear plant. I guess the calculation goes like this: 25 / 90 x 5 = 1.39 large nuclear power stations.

Looking at BP data from 2023, that might already be an exaggeration of the capacity factor of Chinese solar and wind. In 2023, solar had a capacity factor of almost 11% and wind almost 23%, so the combined capacity factor will be much less than 25% (it is almost 16%).

Then another admission follows (my emphasis):

Somewhat counterintuitively, China has built dozens of coal-fired power stations alongside its renewable energy zones, to maintain the pace of its clean energy transition.

Building coal plants “to maintain the pace of its clean energy transition”? Orwell would be proud. Also, “dozens”? That is deliciously vague. Why not a clear number like was done with new solar and wind capacity? That made me wonder how much coal capacity is build compared to solar and wind capacity? Looking at the new coal fired power stations in 2023, the newly build capacity in China is 47,444 MW (= 47.44 GW), a huge increase compared to the two previous years:

Global Coal Plant Tracker: newly added coal capacity (China)

47.4 GW/year divided by 52 is 0.9 GW/week. That is the capacity of, ahem, one large nuclear power plant 😉
That is less than the new capacity of solar and wind, but it is still a significant amount.

Let’s now try to figure out how far behind Australia is and what the Australians could learn from China. The article was about electricity generation, so I went to the World In Data China data, straight to the chapter on electricity.

This is the evolution of the share of fossil fuel in electricity generation:

WorldInData: China vs Australia: share fossil fuel electricity

China’s share of fossil fuel in electricity generation is at 64,7% while Australia does slightly better with 63.9%. The trajectory is also a bit different. Australia had a higher share than China, but there was a sharp turn in 2018 which didn’t happen in China, therefore surpassing China in 2023.

What about low-carbon sources (solar, wind, hydro, nuclear,…)? The article mentions that Australia struggles with hydro and it also doesn’t have nuclear. China does have nuclear and according to the article, the Chinese are churning out pumped hydro installations. So, certainly the Chinese will have the advantage here?

Alas:

WorldInData: China vs Australia: share low-carbon in electricity

It is Australia again that, despite being in the disadvantage of having problems adding hydro to the mix and in the absence of nuclear, is surpassing China. There was also an steeper increase since 2018, therefore surpassing China in 2023.

According to the article, the Chinese are building solar and wind installation at a rapid pace, teaching Australia (and the rest of the world) a lesson. Does that somehow show in the data?

Nope:

WorldInData: China vs Australia: share renewables in electricity

Again, Australia takes the lead. Starting from 2018, there is a steep increase of the share of renewables and Australia surpassed China in 2021.

Share of a certain source doesn’t say everything. This is the comparison electricity production by source of China compared to Australia:

WorldInData: China vs Australia: electricity production by source

Production of electricity strongly increases in China and slightly increases/stabilizes in Australia. Although coal has a decreasing share in electricity production, in absolute terms, coal is still strongly on the rise in China. In Australia, coal use is on its way back.

The article is about electricity, but decarbonizing the energy of a country is more than just decarbonizing electricity. For example, coal is not only used for generating electricity, but also in the industry and for heating. Let’s look at how energy in general is doing. This is the energy consumption by source:

WorldInData: China vs Australia; energy consumption by source

Again, coal use is on the rise in China and on a decrease in Australia.

This is how consumption of energy is changing compared to the previous year (2023 vs 2022):

WorldInData: China change consumption energy sources

By far the biggest risers are coal and oil, followed by solar and wind. Surprisingly, the biggest descender is hydro.

Compare this to the change in Australia:

WorldInData: Australia change consumption energy sources

Although oil is het biggest riser, it is closely followed by solar and later also wind. Coal is among the descenders, but it is gas that is the strongest descender.

What about this “recent” drop in emissions? Is that visible in the annual emission data from World in Data?

WorldInData: China emissions 1907 - 2022

Again nope. China’s emissions are still going up. This is only until 2022, but the BP Statistical Review of World Energy gives in its Emission from Energy table a value for 2023 that is higher than 2022.

That “recent” drop in emissions is most likely somewhere in this year? I heard the “this may mean the country’s emissions have peaked” story before and that was only a temporary slowdown. My guess is that this is going to be the same now. If there currently is a drop in emissions, then it is my guess that it is caused by the property crisis China is experiencing now which has serious repercussions for the economy (the property market makes up a third of its economic output). Once this crisis is dealt with, emissions will most likely rise again.

What about Australia:

WorldInData: Australia emissions 1750 - 2022

Australia’s emissions are stable or decreasing since 2010. Also here, the data goes until 2022, but the 2023 datapoint in the BP data is lower than 2022.

Basically, I fail to see what China is supposed to teach Australia. Whether one understand “decarbonizing” as cutting emissions or decreasing the share of fossil fuels, it is clearly Australia that is leading, not China.

Although China is behind Australia, China apparently already met its 2030 goal by now, while Australia is behind in meeting its 2030 goals. To me, that means that China’s goal was set much lower than that of Australia and then it is of course easier to meet it. That China already met its 2030 goal is therefore not evidence that China is ahead of the game, it just means that their bar is set lower.

I think it is China that could learn a thing or two from Australia regarding decarbonization, not the other way around. If Australia really wants to follow in the footsteps of guide country China, it could maybe start lowering its 2030 goals and start churning out coal power plants, just to keep the pace of its clean energy transition of course. 😉 Then Australia would in no time meet its 2030 goal, just as its shining example China did.

via Trust, yet verify

https://ift.tt/bYI0uP7

July 31, 2024 at 04:00PM