Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Thursday

0 out of 10 based on 0 rating

via JoNova

https://ift.tt/nGgf42Q

July 31, 2024 at 09:33AM

Virginia’s risk of offshore wind turbine blade failure is serious

From CFACT

by David Wojick

On July 26, CFACT’s President Craig Rucker sent Virginia Governor Glenn Youngkin a letter warning him about the serious risk of blade failure in the giant offshore wind facility being built off Virginia. The warning builds on the recent blade failure off of Nantucket, which has littered the beaches with fiberglass fragments. Virginia is also at risk.

In this article, I present some technical background on that risk. The facility will be one of the world’s biggest, with 176 enormous turbines. It is just getting started with pile driving, so no turbine blades have been installed to date. This is an opportune time to undertake caution.

The Nantucket turbines are made by GE, and they are the world’s largest in operation today at 13 MW, each driven by three huge 107-meter-long blades. That is 351 feet for those of us who do not speak metric. The Virginia turbines will be even bigger at 14 MW with 108 meters (154+ feet) long. They are made by Siemens Gamesa, or SG for short.

The GE turbines and blades have been in production for going on two years, so have some operational experience. The SG turbines and blades just came into production so there is no experience with them. One could say they are being beta tested off Virginia.

This newness in itself is a great concern. At three blades each, there are an incredible 528 blades with a combined length of over 57,000 meters (187,000 feet or 35 miles) of blades. To take first production blades to these huge lengths is surely very risky.

Multiple or even systemic failures are certainly possible. A sound engineering approach would be to build a few and see how they did over time. Note, too, that the prototypes were in Europe, so these blades have never been tested in a hurricane, which offshore Virginia is prone to get.

Now let’s look at the blade stress physics just a bit, as it is amazing. SG has a quick look on their website, saying this:

“The rotational forces found in offshore wind turbines in operation put IMMENSE STRAIN ON THE BLADES and the rest of the wind turbine structure. (Emphasis added) At a tip speed of approximately 90 meters per second – equivalent to 324 kilometers per hour! (201 mph!) – and a projected lifetime of more than 25 years, high-quality and innovative design is imperative. For a 108-meter-long blade, the rotational forces are around a staggering 80 million newton meters, and the strain on the blades and the structure is intense! To put this into perspective, the force pulling on a human shoulder while spinning a 1 kg object around in an outstretched arm is only about 10 newton meters!”

(80 million newton meters is about 59 million pound-feet of torque).

Given these immense, intense strains, the novelty of the SG blades becomes even more of an issue.

To begin with, they are constructed in an unusual way. GE and other major manufacturers build half a lengthwise blade at a time, then glue the two halves together. Building half a tube is relatively simple, just lining a trough-like mold with fiberglass. Gravity is your friend, and inspection is easy.

In contrast, SG builds the entire tubular blade at once. I have no idea how, but it cannot be simple. Gravity wants to distort the tube, and inspection must be difficult. In addition, while SG has built a lot of smaller blades this full tube way, their giant blades are of a different composition. Because of the extreme stresses, they have added carbon fibers.

In summary, we have a newly huge blade, subject to immense stresses, made for the first time in an unusual way with a new composition and never tested in a hurricane. The high novelty risk to Virginia is obvious.

But there is another big risk issue as well, a business issue if you like. SG no longer exists as a corporation. It was absorbed by its majority stockholder to keep it from going under. The reason, as Reuters puts it, is “quality issues and ramp-up problems caused a 4.6 billion euro (5 billion dollar) annual net loss.”

In Virginia, we are looking at the biggest wind turbine ramp-up in history, where high quality is imperative. One has to wonder if SG is capable of this prodigious task at this time, and that wonder signals a big risk. Not only does SG have a deep history of problems, they are undergoing restructuring.

Given these novelty-laden circumstances, it surely is unwise to try to throw up 35 miles of untested blades without further consideration. Hence Craig Rucker’s letter to Governor Youngkin.

Image Idaho National Laboratory Creative Commons

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/wTq5rvf

July 31, 2024 at 08:17AM

Are Heatwaves Getting Worse?

By Paul Homewood

 

As promised, I am returning to the Met Office’s State of the UK Climate Report:

 

 

 image

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/news-and-media/media-centre/weather-and-climate-news/2024/temperature-extremes-and-records-most-affected-by-uks-changing-climate

The press release made this claim:

 

Climate change is causing a dramatic increase in the frequency of temperature extremes and number of temperature records the UK experiences.

New analysis of observations shows that extremes of temperature in the UK are most affected by human induced climate change. This means the UK is seeing, on average, more frequent periods of hot weather, bringing challenges for infrastructure, health and wellbeing.

Using an example of 28°C, the frequency of days reaching this threshold has increased nearly everywhere across the UK. Where in the 1961-1990 averaging period only London and Hampshire recorded six or more days over 28°C, by the latest decade (2014-2023) this has spread across much of England and Wales, with frequencies in the south east increasing to over 12 days each year in many counties.

.

Their methodology of counting days when a temperature of 28C has been recorded somewhere has no statistical significance whatsoever, because the sites are changing all the time. We know that they have introduced dozens of poorly sited weather stations in recent years, which regularly feature as daily record highs, and are often two or three degrees higher than nearby sites. We also know how UHI has boosted temperature readings in recent years.

For the methodology to be reliable, it needs to be based on a fixed set of stations. I have therefore analysed temperatures at Radcliffe Observatory in Oxford. The chart below counts the number of days when temperatures were over 28C:

image

https://climexp.knmi.nl/data/xgdcnUK000056225.dat

.

On the face of it, I see little of concern.

The summer of 2018 sticks out with 23 days, the same number as in 1911 and 1995. There were 21 days in 1976 as well.

In most summers we may get about five days or so of hot weather; why should this be a cause of alarm?

Moreover Oxford is a hotter place than it was a century ago because of UHI. I can’t claim any scientific basis for what follows, but if we count the number of days >27C for the years up to 1970, and then add on the number of days >28C since 1970, we get this:

image

This assumes, of course, that Oxford’s temperatures since 1970 have been increased by 1C because of UHI. This is an extremely simplistic assumption!! But I don’t think it is an unreasonable one in principle. My guess would be that the UHI effect since 1911 is probably a lot more than 1C.

The graph shows that there is no trend in hot days, certainly not since the mid 19thC.

1911 appears at the top of the list, bearing out the news reports at the time which graphically described the severity of the summer long heatwave, not only in Britain, but also in France.

But other years in years past also stand out, such as 1826 and 1868.

But even if there is no UHI in Oxford, which would be a ridiculous claim, the worst that is happening is that we now get days of 28C, which 150 years ago might have been 27C instead.

And it is certainly not bringing challenges for infrastructure, health and wellbeing.

via NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

https://ift.tt/96DnRul

July 31, 2024 at 06:35AM

New reconstruction shows low Arctic sea ice cover in mid-20th century


The study thinks late 20th century warming is greater than its mid-20th century results because of anthropogenic factors. But having accepted some warming was and is due to natural variation, it’s largely a matter of opinion whether it’s not all or mostly due to that. The article claims there’s ‘ongoing sea ice area decline’ in the Arctic, but data shows the trend is minimal since the low point of 2007 despite ongoing CO2 increase.
– – –
An international research team presented a new reconstruction of past Arctic sea ice that revealed low levels of sea ice coverage in the 1940s, says Eurekalert.

Their results were published on July 26 in a special issue of Advances in Atmospheric Sciences commemorating the life work of Professor Yongqi Gao who passed away in July 2021. The new reconstruction can help climate scientists adjust expectations of future sea ice coverage.

“Understanding the range of sea ice multi-decadal variations in the past, when the anthropogenic forcing was several times weaker than in the present day, is key for assessing mechanisms of climate variations and predicting future changes of the Arctic sea ice,” said study co-author Vladimir Semenov from the A.M. Obukhov Institute of Atmospheric Physics, Russian Academy of Sciences.
. . .
Since the late 1970s, satellites have been continuously observing seasonal variations of Arctic sea ice over decades.

Sea ice variations have been relatively well monitored since the 1950s, but due to a lack of observations, there are no reliable estimates of the Arctic sea ice area in the middle of the 20th century. This period was characterized by a strong warming, known as the Early 20th Century Warming.

Previous studies established the link between surface air temperature and sea ice, which implies that the early 20th Century warming interval was accompanied by a concurrent reduction of Arctic sea ice, but the magnitude and extent of the decline were unclear.

The research team set out to understand the mystery surrounding sea ice anomalies during the 1940s, a period that instrumental observations indicate was almost as warm as today, according to study co-author Noel Keenlyside.

“Surprisingly, previous reconstructions of sea ice do not indicate a large reduction of sea ice,” said Keenlyside from the Geophysical Institute, University of Bergen and Bjerknes Centre for Climate Research.

The team reconstructed the sea ice patterns in the period with poor data, before 1953, using established co-variability patterns between sea ice, sea surface temperature, and sea level pressure patterns.

Constructing distinct regression models for three geographically separated regions — the Arctic Ocean, Bering Sea and the Sea of Okhotsk — improved the fit of the models and reduced uncertainty.

“Our reconstruction using independent data provides the first strong evidence for a large decline of sea ice in the 1940s,” Keenlyside said. “This is exciting, because unlike the present warming, emitted anthropogenic greenhouse gases were relatively low.”

The reconstruction, called the Institute of Atmospheric Physics sea ICE reconstruction version 1, provides a new baseline for assessing internal climate variability.

According to the study, the ongoing sea ice area decline is already significantly beyond the level of internal climate variability — even assuming that the Early 20th Century Warming of the Arctic was primarily caused by internal climate variability.

This indicates the importance of the anthropogenic forcing [Talkshop comment – belief-based assertion].

Full article here.
– – –
Image: Arctic Ocean ice Sept. 9, 2009 [credit: Wikipedia]

via Tallbloke’s Talkshop

https://ift.tt/8oKgPcM

July 31, 2024 at 05:00AM