Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Ford’s EV Bloodbath Continues

From the Robert Bryce Substack

Robert Bryce

FoMoCo lost $47,585 for each EV sold in Q2, GE Vernova calls offshore turbine blade failure a “manufacturing deviation”

Photo by author.

The losses keep coming. As I reported here in February, Ford Motor Co. lost $4.7 billion on its EV business in 2023, or about $64,731 for each EV it sold. Today, the company reported that over the first two quarters, it has lost nearly $2.5 billion on its Model e segment, meaning Ford’s EV losses are on track to total $5 billion in 2024. While the company’s per-vehicle losses declined somewhat during the second quarter, they are still stunning. Let’s take a quick drive through the results.

On July 3, the company published its second-quarter sales numbers. Its EV sales totaled 23,957 units, up 61% from the same period in 2023.

But the money numbers were published today, and they are sobering. Yes, the company sold 23,957 EVs during the quarter, but it lost $1.14 billion while doing so. Thus, Ford lost $47,585 for each EV it sold. In a press release, the company said it incurred the loss “amid ongoing industrywide pricing pressure on first-generation electric vehicles and lower wholesales. Those factors more than offset about $400 million in year-over-year cost reductions in the segment.”

In plain English, the company is saying that its cost-cutting efforts aren’t enough to make up for the price cuts it is being forced to make to attract buyers. To put that $47,585 per-EV loss in perspective, a Ford dealer in Austin currently has more than 20 Mustang Mach-E vehicles in stock selling for less than $47,000.  

A bit more background on the company’s sales helps illustrate the scale of Ford’s faltering EV business. During the second quarter, Ford sold 199,463 F-Series trucks. Further, it sold more than half a million internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEVs). Thus, as seen above, the Dearborn-based auto giant sold 21 times more ICEVs than EVs.

The ongoing disaster in EVs has (finally) awakened Ford’s leaders from their money-losing stupor. Last Thursday, the company announced it would spend $3 billion to expand production capacity for its super-profitable F-Series line. In a July 18 press release, it said to meet “customer demand for one of its most popular and profitable vehicles,” it will add “initial capacity for 100,000 F-Series Super Duty trucks, including future multi-energy technology, at Oakville Assembly Complex in Ontario, Canada.” The press release also contains some telling words from the company’s COO, Kumar Galhotra:

This investment will benefit Ford, our employees in Canada and the U.S., and especially our customers who want and need Super Duty for their lives and livelihoods… It is fully consistent with our Ford+ plan for profitable growth, as we take steps to maximize our global manufacturing footprint, and our investments will have a fast payback. (Emphasis added.)

In other words, Ford has decided profitability matters. Rather than continue pouring money into its money-burning EV business, it will expand the production of the vehicles that keep the lights on, which means producing more F-150s and other vehicles that burn dino juice.

One final note that gives more proof that the EV craze is running out of steam: On Tuesday, General Motors CEO Mary Barra told Wall Street analysts that her company is deferring investments in EVs to ensure, as the Wall Street Journal put it, “the company doesn’t get ahead of demand.”

A broken turbine blade on a GE Vernova turbine at the Vineyard Wind project.

GE Vernova’s Wind Turbine Orders Plummet, CEO Calls Blade Failure “Manufacturing Deviation”

In the annals of corporate gobbledygook, Scott Strazik, the CEO of GE Vernova (GEV), surely deserves a prize for using the phrase “manufacturing deviation” to explain the July 13 disintegration of a turbine blade at the Vineyard Wind project in Massachusetts waters offshore Nantucket.

Yesterday, during an investor call to discuss the company’s second-quarter financials, Strazik addressed the disintegration of the turbine blade. As you may recall, that blade failure sent tons of debris into the ocean, forcing the temporary closure of beaches on Nantucket Island during the height of the summer tourist season. The turbine blade disaster also led to a suspension of construction on the 800-megawatt offshore project, which is owned by two foreign companies, Avangrid, and Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners, while investigators try to figure out what happened.

During the call, Strazik explained the blade was made in a factory in Canada and that “our investigation to date indicates that the affected blade experienced a manufacturing deviation.”

What, exactly, does that mean? The MV Times reported that “GE Vernova later issued an email statement that the manufacturing issue was due to ‘insufficient bonding,’ although they didn’t offer further explanation. Vernova — whose offices are in Cambridge — has not returned multiple calls to offer an explanation.”

GE Vernova’s second-quarter results revealed the slow-rolling train wreck now underway in the wind industry. While the company announced an increase in revenue and profits, it also revealed that its wind-related order book decreased “primarily due to a large Offshore Wind equipment order in the second quarter of last year that was canceled in the fourth quarter.”

The press release continued, noting that orders for new wind turbines plummeted 44%, and wind segment revenues fell 21% during the quarter. The company’s wind segment was the only one to lose money during the quarter. While the power segment made $613 million in EBITDA and the electrification segment made $129 million, the wind segment lost $117 million.

As I noted earlier this week in “Breaking Wind,” the wind industry faces lots of pain. More proof came last Friday when Level Ten Energy reported that power purchase agreement prices for new wind projects jumped by 13.5% year-on-year. Solar prices increased by about 3%.  Thus, Big Wind is not only seeing lots of turbine failures onshore and offshore and a growing backlash across America — where local governments and landowners are rejecting the encroachment of their monstrous landscape-destroying-wildlife-killing-whale-endangering-and-property-value-shredding machines — it is also losing price competitiveness in the market.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/TDjQ9EO

July 26, 2024 at 08:04AM

Milloy talks windmill corruption on FOX Business

From the July 25, 2024 episode of The Bottom Line on FOX Business.

via JunkScience.com

https://ift.tt/JU7Ovfi

July 26, 2024 at 06:07AM

1-minute Junking: Emissions cause rainfall variability?

Related links: Science study

via JunkScience.com

https://ift.tt/QsIZvdo

July 26, 2024 at 06:07AM

CfDs: Facts v Myths

By Paul Homewood

 

NZW has a long detailed analysis of how CfDs work.

I would like to add some actual numbers to it:

 

 image

Advocates of wind and solar electricity argue that Contracts for Difference (CfDs) are good value because they deliver green power at fixed prices, which protect us from volatility in the fossil fuel market. Critics argue that wind and solar CfDs are expensive relative to the alternatives, and that this reveals that the claimed cost reductions in these technologies under the Levelised Cost of Electricity (LCOE) metric are illusory when one takes into account a wider range of factors that cannot be avoided in reality. How should we judge the value of CfDs?

At one level, the CfD itself reveals whether it is costing or saving money. It guarantees a fixed value (the strike price) to the operator, regardless of market prices. If the market reference price is more than the strike price, the operator has to pay the difference to the Low Carbon Contracts Company (LCCC), which administers the scheme. This value is a net gain to electricity customers. If the market reference price is less than the strike price, the LCCC pays the operator the difference, so as to ensure it receives the strike price in the round. This value is then a net loss to electricity customers.

To date, strike prices have mostly been well above the market reference price. Consumers have had to contribute material sums to pay wind and solar operators their premium over the market value. However, for around a year from late 2021, when prices surged, the strike prices were below the market reference prices on average, and CfDs saved consumers some money.

https://www.netzerowatch.com/all-news/the-cost-of-contracts-for-difference

 

 

It is misleading to say that “for around a year from late 2021, when prices surged, the strike prices were below the market reference prices on average, and CfDs saved consumers some money”, as the graph below shows:

 

 image

https://dp.lowcarboncontracts.uk/dataset/actual-cfd-generation-and-avoided-ghg-emissions

.

To date, the subsidy bill for CfD has amounted to £10.6billion. Even during 2022, when gas prices spiked, consumers still had to pay £1.3 billion to subsidise renewables. It may be true that savings were made for short periods during that time, and also that some of the lower prices contracts returned money to consumers. But overall CfDs still cost consumers money during 2022.

While this was less than the year before, it should also be pointed out that during the lockdowns of 2020 energy prices fell sharply, meaning that the subsidy paid was much greater. Indeed, taking 2020 and 2022 together, it is apparent that electricity customers were much worse off overall.

.

The analysis also questions whether CfDs will save us money in future:

“With the plans (of all incumbent parties, though Labour’s are the ones that now count) to massively increase the amount of wind and solar on the grid, future costs are more important than the historic figures. Proponents claim that the costs of these technologies are still falling. The future costs of fossil fuels and other technologies (e.g. nuclear) are uncertain. So the past (as usual) is not necessarily a guide to the future. Perhaps CfDs will become a way, not only of delivering green electricity, but also of saving consumers money? That is a common claim, not only of eco-socialists, but also of so-called free-market environmentalists.

I don’t pretend to know. Cost trends are not endlessly linear, but neither is it easy to know when the discontinuity will occur. Those who claim to know that they won’t save consumers’ money make the same mistake as those who claim to know that they will. We will find out in due course. But we can at least be clear how that judgment should be made.”

.

While it is stating the obvious to say that nobody knows what fossil fuel prices will be in the future, the analysis is remiss in not stating the costs that we do know now– the Administrative Strike Prices set for this year’s CfD auction. Offshore wind, in particular, is currently priced at around £102/MWh. We also know that the wholesale electricity prices have ranged between around £60 and £70/MWh this year, and that these sort of prices are consistent with historical trends prior to the pandemic and Ukraine war:

image

OFGEM

 

Given the facts we do have at hand, while diversity of energy supply is important, there is clearly not an economic case for continuance of CfDs. Investors should take the risk themselves, and not customers.

via NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

https://ift.tt/Cs9x4MS

July 26, 2024 at 05:01AM