Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Nikolov & Zeller: Misrepresentation of Critical Satellite Data by IPCC

  1. Introduction

The 6th Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC AR6) concluded “It is very likely that well-mixed GHGs [greenhouse gases] were the main driver of tropospheric warming since 1979” (IPCC, 2021; p.5). This statement implies that all known climate forcings have properly been evaluated using the available data, and GHGs have been found to exert a disproportionally large radiative effect on the Global Surface Air Temperature (GSAT) over the past 45 years. However, a close examination of Chapter 7 of the Working Group I (WG1) Contribution to the IPCC AR6 (Forster et al. 2021), which discusses the Earth’s energy budget, climate feedbacks and climate sensitivity, reveals that the observed decrease of Earth’s albedo and the corresponding increase of absorbed shortwave radiation by the Planet for the past 20 years have not been taken into account as contributors to the recent warming. Section 7.2.2 of Chapter 7 entitled “Changes in Earth’s Energy Budget” acknowledges that there have been multidecadal periods of significant decreasing and increasing trends in surface solar radiation (SSR) called “global dimming” (i.e. from 1950s to 1980s) and “global brightening” (after 1980s), respectively. The report states: “There is high confidence that these [SSR] trends are widespread, and not localized phenomena or measurement artefacts.” Indeed, the existence of such dimming and brightening multidecadal periods has been acknowledged by science for more than 10 years (Stanhill et al. 2014; Yuan et al. 2021), but the IPCC AR6 provides no global estimate of the observed positive trend in SSR since 1980s and its impact on GSAT. Instead, the Report simply states “The origin of these trends is not fully understood”.

With respect to the top-of-the-atmosphere (TOA) solar fluxes, Section 7.2.2 of the IPCC AR WG1 offers no analysis of the substantial decrease in Earth’s shortwave reflectance since 2000 observed by the NASA’s Clouds and the Earth’s Radiant Energy System (CERES) project (Loeb et al. 2018, 2019, 2020 and 2021) and also reported by other research teams (e.g. Dübal & Vahrenholt 2021; Stephens et al. 2022). The Report does not discuss the observed 2.0 W m-2 increase in solar-energy uptake by the Planet from 2000 to 2020 nor its contribution to the recent warming. What is even more puzzling, Subsection 7.2.2.1 of the IPCC AR6 WG1 Contribution features graphs in their Fig. 7.3 (on p. 936) showing an increasing reflected solar flux and decreasing outgoing thermal flux since 2000 that are supposedly based on CERES data. However, these trends are opposite of what CERES has actually measured and directly contradict results reported by prior studies. This article presents findings from our investigation of Fig. 7.3 in the IPCC AR6.

  • Figure 7.3 in the IPCC AR6 WG1 Contribution

Page 936 of the IPCC Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis (IPCC, 2021) contains the following figure:

Panel (a) of Fig. 7.3 shows anomalies of the reflected solar flux, panel (b) depicts anomalies of the emitted (outgoing) thermal (longwave) flux, and panel (c) displays net-flux anomalies calculated as a difference between absorbed solar shortwave (SW) and outgoing longwave (LW) anomalies. Since reflection is opposite of absorption, the absorbed SW anomalies are obtained by simply multiplying the reflected solar anomalies by -1. Figure 7.3 also portrays simulation results from 7 climate models that were forced by observed sea-surface temperatures (SST) and sea-ice boundary conditions. Note that the CERES data are depicted as thick black lines while the multi-model means are shown as thick red lines.

The problem with IPCC’s Fig. 7.3 is that the plots of reflected solar and outgoing thermal radiation show opposite temporal trends compared to trends of the same fluxes found in the actual CERES dataset. Figures 1 and 2 below illustrate this fact. At the same time, the net flux (a.k.a. the Earth’s Energy Imbalance or EEI) shows a correct trend (Fig. 3).

Figure 1. Trends of Earth’s reflected solar radiation in the CERES dataset (upper panel) and the IPCC AR6 WG1 Fig. 7.3(a) (lower panel). Note that the 13- vs. 12-month running means do not affect the long-term flux trends.

Figure 2. Trends of Earth’s outgoing thermal radiation in the CERES dataset (upper panel) and the IPCC AR6 WG1 Fig. 7.3(b) (lower panel). Note that the 13- vs. 12-month running means do not affect the long-term flux trends.

Figure 3. Trends of Earth’s net radiative flux (energy imbalance) in the CERES dataset (upper panel) and the IPCC AR6 WG1 Fig. 7.3(c) (lower panel). Note that the trend of the net flux has not been altered in the IPCC’s Fig. 7.3. Note that the 13- vs. 12-month running means do not affect the long-term flux trends.

We discovered this trend issue while working on a paper evaluating the contribution of Earth’s observed albedo decrease since 2000 to recent warming using the CERES dataset.

Upon a close examination, it became clear to us that the trend inversion of reflected solar and emitted thermal flux anomalies appeared to have been achieved by multiplying the original data series by -1.0. The text of the IPCC AR6 referring to Fig. 7.3 does not mention anything about altering the trends of key global energy-budget parameters, nor does it provide a clear explanation of the reason behind it. However, the caption of Fig. 7.3 contains the following peculiar sentence “All flux anomalies are defined as positive downwards, consistent with the sign convention used throughout this chapter.” This statement is perplexing, because flux anomalies are independent of the flux direction. Anomalies are simply departures of timeseries data from an arbitrary reference value. In the case of the CERES dataset, flux anomalies are calculated with respect to the mean value of the deseasonalized timeseries over the entire observational period. Hence, the choice of a reference value solely determines, whether an anomaly is positive or negative irrespective of the flux direction. In other words, the sign of an anomaly is not subject to the definition of a positive flux direction as suggested by the caption of Fig. 7.3. Furthermore, calculating the anomalies of an environmental parameter (such as global temperature, ocean heat content, radiative flux etc.) does not change the temporal trend of the original data set. This is basic knowledge in the field of climate science. In this regard, the statement in the caption of Fig. 7.3 relating anomalies to a flux direction is physically meaningless and confusing.

Another problem with the IPCC Fig. 7.3 is that the net-flux anomalies shown in panel (c), whose trend has not been altered, cannot be calculated from the timeseries shown in panels (a) and (b) as expected. Since the net-flux anomaly is a difference between anomalies of the absorbed solar and emitted thermal fluxes, the data curves on the graph in panel (c) are numerically incompatible with those plotted in panels (a) and (b).

  • Correspondence with IPCC Authors about Fig. 7.3.

In an effort to clarify the above situation, we reached out to the Coordinating Lead Authors of Chapter 7 in the IPCC AR6 WG1 Contribution, Prof. Piers Forster at the University of Leeds (UK) and Prof. Trude Storelvmo at the University of Oslo (Norway). We asked them, who the authors of Section 7.2.2 in Chapter 7 were, where Fig. 7.3 appears. Prof. Forster promptly replied informing us that Section 7.2.2 was written and edited by Dr. Matthew Palmer at the University of Bristol and UK’s Met Office (UK) and Dr. Chris Smith at the University of Leeds (UK). Dr. Palmer was the lead author of that Section. Prof. Forster also provided us with a link to the IPCC AR6 WG1 repository at GitHub.com, where all data files and Python processing scripts reside used to generate the figures appearing in the WG1 Report.

We searched the GitHub repository and found three text files containing the source data for Fig. 7.3 as well as a Python plotting script used to generate the actual figure panels. There was a TXT file for every panel of Fig. 7.3 providing both CERES observations and climate-model projections covering the period July 2000 – June 2017. Upon inspecting the data files and the Python script, we discovered that, indeed, the deseasonalized monthly anomalies of reflected solar and emitted thermal fluxes have been multiplied by -1 resulting in inversion of the original trends, and that this data manipulation occurred in the Python script generating the panels of Fig. 7.3. The text files contained unaltered data that exhibit correct trends. Figure 4 depicts the anomalies of reflected solar and outgoing thermal fluxes from CERES observations and climate-model simulations as found in the text data files on GitHub. Figure 5 shows a portion of the Python script, where the signs of shortwave (SW) and longwave (LW) anomalies (code parameters SW_dict and LW_dict) are inverted during the plotting process by placing a minus sign in front of the corresponding data arrays. The Python script was utilized to invert the trends of both the CERES data and climate-model projections.       

Figure 4. Plots of TOA reflected solar and outgoing thermal flux anomalies found in text data files at the IPCC GitHub repository and used to generate Fig. 7.3 in the IPCC AR6 WG1. These data show correct trends.

Figure 5. Portion of the Python script used by the IPCC authors of Section 7.2.2 to plot the TOA anomalies of reflected shortwave (SW), emitted longwave (LW) and net fluxes from both CERES observations and climate model projections. Note the minus sign in front of the arrays containing SW and LW flux data.  

It is worth noting that, although the climate models correctly reproduced the overall pattern of observed changes in planetary SW and LW fluxes, the measured trends of these variables are much steeper compared to the modeled ones. Most importantly, the climate models significantly underestimate the rate of decrease of Earth’s albedo and the associated increase of absorbed solar radiation by the Planet since 2000. The rate of planetary cooling (i.e. emitted thermal flux) was also significantly lower in the model simulations compared to observations. A key detail in this comparison is that all models have been forced with observed sea-surface temperatures (SST) and sea-ice boundary conditions. Had the models been only guided by their internal physical processes without periodic nudging by real world observations, the above model-data correlation would likely have been much worse or even of opposite sign.

On July 8, 2024, we sent an email message to Dr. Palmer and Dr. Smith informing them about the findings from our search of the GitHub data repository and asking them to explain the reason for the trend inversion of the SW and LW flux anomalies in Fig. 7.3. We also sought their advice about whether to use the timeseries shown in Fig. 7.3 or the data found in the source text files, if we decide to create customized graphs of TOA fluxes for a review paper we’ve been working on.

We received a reply from Dr. Palmer on July 10, 2024, where he acknowledged that the reflected solar and outgoing thermal flux anomalies had intentionally been multiplied by -1. However, his explanation for this data manipulation was simply an expansion of the justification stated in the caption of Fig. 7.3 that invoked flux direction. Specifically, Dr. Palmer wrote:

“… reflected SW and outgoing LW are both defined as positive in the upward/outward direction. Therefore, for those timeseries we multiply by -1 so that they are expressed in a way that is consistent with the rest of the chapter. This means, for example, that a decrease in reflected SW means a relative GAIN of energy in the Earth system. Similarly, an increase in outgoing LW means a relative LOSS of energy in the Earth system. Note that in the figure we label these as “global solar flux anomaly” and “global thermal flux anomaly” rather than “reflected SW flux” and “outgoing LW flux”.”

As discussed above, this explanation makes no physical sense, because anomalies are always defined with respect to a chosen reference value and, therefore, have nothing to do with flux direction. Also, expressing a timeseries in terms of anomalies is not supposed to change the trend of the original data. Dr. Palmer correctly pointed out that multiplying anomalies of the reflected solar flux by -1 produces a timeseries of a relative energy gain by the system. This new timeseries is called absorbed solar flux, because reflection is opposite of (and complementary to) absorption. Hence, panel (a) of the IPCC Fig. 7.3 essentially shows anomalies of the absorbed solar flux by Earth. The problem is that the caption of Fig. 7.3 labels this panel as “reflected solar”, which is misleading. Since Dr. Palmer mislabeled the flux in the figure caption while recognizing that Fig. 7.3 (a) depicts a relative gain of solar energy by the Earth system, this obscured a key natural driver of climate related to the Sun.

On the other hand, multiplying anomalies of the outgoing thermal flux by -1 does not produce anything meaningful, because (unlike the solar flux) Earth’s LW radiation is always directed outward and does not have a complementary flux directed inward. By showing a decreasing thermal emission from Earth over time as done in Fig. 7.3 (b), the authors of Section 7.2.2 (Dr. Palmer and Dr. Smith) suggest a “heat trapping” in the climate system by increasing concentrations of atmospheric greenhouse gases. However, the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics makes it impossible for an open system with a rising surface temperature such as Earth to have a decreasing emission of outgoing thermal radiation. In other words, by inverting the trend of the TOA outgoing LW flux, the IPCC authors have misrepresented the physical reality! 

Interestingly, Dr. Palmer advised us to use the data in the text files found in the GitHub repository in case we wanted to create customized plots of CERES and modeled radiative fluxes. We interpreted this as an acknowledgement that the correct data were contained in the text files rather than Fig. 7.3.

In our reply to Dr. Palmer, we listed a series of specific concerns that the trend inversion of reflected solar and outgoing thermal fluxes made in Fig. 7.3 was methodologically inappropriate, because it fundamentally changes the observed behavior of the climate system over the past 20 years and creates a false impression about climate drivers in the minds of researchers and politicians reading the IPCC Report. Dr. Palmer did not address our concerns and instead directed us toward an official IPCC webpage, where we could further raise the issue. Although he did not recognize the misrepresentation of satellite data in Fig. 7.3, it is possible that he was genuinely confused about flux anomalies and how they are calculated, since he made the following odd statement in one of his replies: “I don’t think there is any fundamental issue here – just different choices about the sign convention used”.

The truth is that the flux-trend inversions in Fig. 7.3 have enormous implications for both IPCC’s main conclusions and the climate theory; thus, they must be exposed and explained to the Public.

  • Implications of the Data Manipulation in the IPCC Fig. 7.3

Figure 7.3 in the IPCC AR6 WG1 essentially shows an increasing planetary albedo (panel a) and a decreasing infrared cooling to Space (panel b) for the past 2 decades, which is diametrically opposite of satellite observations. While the text of the IPCC WG1 Chapter 7 does not discuss any long-term trends of the TOA reflected solar and emitted thermal fluxes in the 21st-Century, Fig. 7.3 subconsciously suggests that the solar forcing played no role in recent warming and the rising concentrations of atmospheric greenhouse gases due to human industrial activity had increased the retention of heat in the climate system by impeding the outgoing LW radiation. These implications of Fig. 7.3 based on manipulated data align perfectly well with the radiative greenhouse theory of climate change, but contradict directly the physical reality as revealed by CERES measurements.

By inverting the trend of reflected solar flux, the IPCC authors effectively eliminated the need to analyze the cloud-controlled solar forcing and its contribution to recent tropospheric warming while reaffirming at the same time the a-priori assumed pivotal role of greenhouse gases in driving the global surface temperature since 2000. The trend inversion of the outgoing thermal flux further solidifies the false impression that the Earth had warmed in response to “heat trapping” by increasing atmospheric trace gases.

Had the IPCC AR6 WG1 acknowledged the ~2.0 W m-2 increase of solar radiation absorption by the Planet between 2000 and 2020 as measured along the 13-month running mean curve of CERES anomalies (Fig. 6), the following conclusions/claims found in the Report’s “Summary for Policy Makers” would have been impossible to defend “It is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land” and “It is very likely that well-mixed GHGs were the main driver of tropospheric warming since 1979” (IPCC, 2021; p.4-5). This is because a solar forcing of 2.0 W m-2 is more than sufficient to explain the entire observed warming for the past 2 decades, thus eliminating the need to invoke any model-generated (i.e. theoretical) radiative forcing by greenhouse gases.

Figure 6. Monthly radiative anomalies of the Earth’s absorbed solar flux estimated from the CERES EBAF 4.2 dataset by multiplying the reported reflected all-sky shortwave anomalies by -1 (in accordance with the fact that absorption is diametrically opposite of reflection).

For example, using the lowest value of IPCC’s transient climate sensitivity estimated from data on GHG radiative forcing and temperature increase presented in Sections 7.3.5.2 and 7.3.5.3 of the IPCC AR6 WG1 Chapter 7 (Forster et al. 2021), i.e. 0.47 K/(W m-2), the warming caused by solar forcing alone for the period 2000 – 2020 should have been 2.0*0.47 = 0.94 K. The observed global surface warming over this time interval (calculated as an average temperature rise from 6 datasets) is 0.62 K along the curve of 13-month running means (Fig. 7). Similar results are obtained, if one uses the linear trends depicted in Figures 6 and 7 instead. Assuming the above IPCC climate sensitivity estimate, the mean decadal increase of Earth’s sunlight absorption measured by CERES (Fig. 6) corresponds to a global surface warming of 0.797*0.47 = 0.37 K/decade, while the actual observed warming is only 0.23 K/decade (Fig. 7). Thus, the observed solar forcing, which is mostly induced by cloud-albedo variations (Loeb et al. 2019), leaves no room for any action by greenhouse-gas radiative forcing or amplifying (positive) feedbacks as speculated by the IPCC AR6. In addition, according to our analysis, the IPCC’s lowest climate sensitivity estimate of 0.47 K/(W m-2) is still an overestimation of the Earth’s actual climate sensitivity, 0.29 K/(W m-2) discussed elsewhere (Nikolov & Zeller, manuscript under review).

Figure 7. Monthly anomalies of the global surface air temperature calculated by averaging values from 6 datasets (HadCRUT5, GISTEMP4, NOAA GlobalTemp, BEST, RSS and NOAA STAR) and a 13-month running mean used to smooth the interannual variability.

In other words, the measured increase of Earth’s sunlight absorption by CERES in the 21st Century, if acknowledged in the IPCC AR6, would have falsified the Report’s central assertion that human carbon emissions were the main driver of climate in recent decades. It is conceivable then that radiative flux anomalies in Fig. 7.3 were manipulated and discussions about long-term CERES trends in Section 7.2.2 were intentionally omitted, precisely because the actual CERES data present a significant empirical challenge (obstacle) to the UN’s political Agenda (established by Resolution A/RES/43/53 of the United Nations General Assembly in 1988) to promote Anthropogenic Climate Change.

  • Conclusion

Considering the above facts and the enormous global socioeconomic impact of the IPCC’s conclusions and recommendations, we believe that it will be in the World’s best interest to launch an independent, critical reevaluation of fundamental premises in the climate theory from the standpoint of modern observations, and establish a new, objective peer-review system that ensures a complete and unbiased representation of all available data in the IPCC Reports. These efforts should be accompanied by a dedicated and decisive depoliticization of climate science through appropriate legislation (International Law) that also incentivizes the adoption of novel approaches to solving climate physics problems.

via Tallbloke’s Talkshop

https://ift.tt/7mkcyG0

July 26, 2024 at 04:43AM

Saharan dust regulates hurricane rainfall

Stanford University

Giant plumes of Sahara Desert dust that gust across the Atlantic can suppress hurricane formation over the ocean and affect weather in North America. 

But thick dust plumes can also lead to heavier rainfall – and potentially more destruction – from landfalling storms, according to a July 24 study in Science Advances. The research shows a previously unknown relationship between hurricane rainfall and Saharan dust plumes. 

“Surprisingly, the leading factor controlling hurricane precipitation is not, as traditionally thought, sea surface temperature or humidity in the atmosphere. Instead, it’s Sahara dust,”

said the corresponding author Yuan Wang, an assistant professor of Earth system science at the Stanford Doerr School of Sustainability.

Previous studies have found that Saharan dust transport may decline dramatically in the coming decades and hurricane rainfall will likely increase due to human-caused climate change. 

However, uncertainty remains around the questions of how climate change will affect outflows of dust from the Sahara and how much more rainfall we should expect from future hurricanes. Additional questions surround the complex relationships among Saharan dust, ocean temperatures, and hurricane formation, intensity, and precipitation. Filling in the gaps will be critical to anticipating and mitigating the impacts of climate change.

“Hurricanes are among the most destructive weather phenomena on Earth,” said Wang. Even relatively weak hurricanes can produce heavy rains and flooding hundreds of miles inland. “For conventional weather predictions, especially hurricane predictions, I don’t think dust has received sufficient attention to this point.”

Competing effects

Dust can have competing effects on tropical cyclones, which are classified as hurricanes in the North Atlantic, central North Pacific, and eastern North Pacific when maximum sustained wind speeds reach 74 miles per hour or higher.

“A dust particle can make ice clouds form more efficiently in the core of the hurricane, which can produce more precipitation,” Wang explained, referring to this effect as microphysical enhancement. Dust can also block solar radiation and cool sea surface temperatures around a storm’s core, which weakens the tropical cyclone.

Wang and colleagues set out to first develop a machine learning model capable of predicting hurricane rainfall, and then identify the underlying mathematical and physical relationships.

The researchers used 19 years of meteorological data and hourly satellite precipitation observations to predict rainfall from individual hurricanes. 

The results show a key predictor of rainfall is dust optical depth, a measure of how much light filters through a dusty plume. They revealed a boomerang-shaped relationship in which rainfall increases with dust optical depths between 0.03 and 0.06, and sharply decreases thereafter. In other words, at high concentrations, dust shifts from boosting to suppressing rainfall.  

“Normally, when dust loading is low, the microphysical enhancement effect is more pronounced. If dust loading is high, it can more efficiently shield [the ocean] surface from sunlight, and what we call the ‘radiative suppression effect’ will be dominant,” Wang said.

Additional authors are affiliated with Western Michigan University, Purdue University, University of Utah, and California Institute of Technology


Journal

Science Advances

DOI

10.1126/sciadv.adn6106

Article Title

Leading Role of Saharan Dust on Tropical Cyclone Rainfall in the Atlantic Basin

Article Publication Date

24-Jul-2024

From EurekAlert!


Abstract

Tropical cyclone rainfall (TCR) extensively affects coastal communities, primarily through inland flooding. The impact of global climate changes on TCR is complex and debatable. This study uses an XGBoost machine learning model with 19-year meteorological data and hourly satellite precipitation observations to predict TCR for individual storms. The model identifies dust optical depth (DOD) as a key predictor that enhances performance evidently. The model also uncovers a nonlinear and boomerang-shape relationship between Saharan dust and TCR, with a TCR peak at 0.06 DOD and a sharp decrease thereafter. This indicates a shift from microphysical enhancement to radiative suppression at high dust concentrations. The model also highlights meaningful correlations between TCR and meteorological factors like sea surface temperature and equivalent potential temperature near storm cores. These findings illustrate the effectiveness of machine learning in predicting TCR and understanding its driving factors and physical mechanisms.

INTRODUCTION

Tropical cyclones (TCs) are extreme weather events that have caused catastrophic damages globally (1, 2). According to global and regional climate models, TC rainfall (TCR) is expected to increase with global warming, following the increased water vapor holding capacity in the atmosphere with rising temperature (3–5). A recent study (6) compared the sea surface temperature (SST)–TCR relationships and discovered that the climate scaling (changing ratio between rainfall and rising temperature) under future warmer climate (5% per K) is smaller than the Clausius-Clapeyron scaling (7% per K) and apparent scaling under current climate. In addition, recent satellite observations revealed a decreasing trend of rain rate in the core part of TCs but increasing trend in outer bands (7, 8). Besides ocean surface temperature and water vapor in the atmosphere, other environmental factors regulate the regional variations of TCR, including vertical wind shear (9–11), surface roughness change (12–14), and atmospheric aerosols (15, 16). How the environment and climate influence the TCR remains unresolved, especially over multiyear to decadal time scales.

Saharan dust, transported across the Atlantic Ocean by trade winds, is the predominant aerosol type during summer and early fall over the tropical Atlantic (17). It can efficiently alter atmospheric radiative fluxes in both shortwave and longwave bands and participate in cloud formation by serving as cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) and/or ice nuclei (IN) (18). It has been reported that Saharan dust tends to suppress the formation of tropical cyclones via a cooling effect on SST that consequently cuts the energy supply for TCs (19, 20). This phenomenon was evident during the peak of European air pollution in the 1970s and 1980s, which is believed to have amplified the Sahel dust emissions due to the prevalent drought conditions. This intensified dust transport coincided with a noticeable downturn in Atlantic hurricane activity (8). Another study (21) has highlighted a close association between the North Atlantic’s dust and considerable spatial shifts in factors such as zonal wind shear, midlevel moisture, and SST. However, they found a minimal correlation between dust optical depth (DOD) and the Atlantic’s accumulated cyclone energy. As Saharan dust-laden air masses move westward, they can introduce dry and stable air into the tropical environment. This dry air inhibits the moisture and convection required for tropical cyclone formation. Moreover, by blocking solar radiation from reaching the surface, dust can reduce SST. The dust effects on TCR can be more complicated and multifaceted. Similar to the anthropogenic aerosols (e.g., sulfate or hygroscopic organics) that provide more CCN to TC systems (22), dust can foster the hydrometeor formation in the cloud tower, enhance the vertical motion of rain bands via elevated latent heat release, and result in more surface precipitation (23). In a nutshell, there is no consensus on the sign of the dust effect on TCR, and it remains uncertain what is the relative importance of dust effect compared to the other meteorological factors.

Current climate models still do not have sufficient spatial resolution to resolve the complex microphysical processes of cloud and precipitation, particularly how aerosol microphysics affects deep convective clouds. While cloud-resolving numerical models were adopted to capture the complex air-sea and aerosol-TC interactions (14, 24), it remains challenging to run these models over multiyear to decadal climate time scales, given their computational expense. Therefore, a combination of big data and machine learning (ML) offers a promising alternative method for untangling those complex relationships between environment forcings and TC activities. Previous studies have demonstrated that ML has robust predictive capabilities in TC genesis, intensity, precipitation, and rapid intensification (14, 25–27). While current ML research on TCs primarily centers on enhancing forecasting and prediction capabilities, ML models also have the potential to unveil intricate and nonlinear relationships between features and response variables. Recent advancements in interpretable ML further bolster the interpretability of these models. Therefore, in this research, we first derive a long-term record of TCR, which is defined as the average tropical cyclone rain rate within 600 km of each TC position (see Materials and Methods), and then aim to: (i) develop an ML model capable of predicting TCR variabilities across the Atlantic Ocean using environmental forcing variables; (ii) pinpoint the most influential environmental forcing variables within the ML model and explore their interactions; and (iii) specifically, elucidate the role of Saharan dust in TCR. This will be achieved by contrasting various ML models with and without the dust variable and interpreting their physical significance through the lens of ML interpretability techniques.

RESULTS

Model performance and overall effect of dust

A correlation analysis first shows very low correlations (coefficient generally smaller than 0.06) between individual environmental factors and TCR (fig. S1). It indicates that conventional statistical methods such as linear regression may not work well to model TCR, likely due to the nonlinear relationships between environmental features and TCR. Therefore, we use a more sophisticated ML approach, the Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) based on an ensemble of decision trees, to build our TCR models. Two distinct models were developed, one only including the traditional meteorological factors and geoinformation and the other adding DOD as another predictor. Results from fivefold cross-validation demonstrate that both DOD and non-DOD models offer decent out-of-sample prediction capabilities (with ~0.6 R2, as in Fig. 1, A and B), without overfitting the training data. Notably, the DOD model surpasses its counterpart, as evidenced by a higher R2 and a reduced root mean squared error (RMSE). The differences in conditional median values further highlight the DOD model’s superiority across most TCR spectrums, with pronounced error reduction observed for both light and heavy TCR extremes (as illustrated in Fig. 1C). Both models tend to have a larger magnitude of underestimates for heavy TCR than the overestimates for light TCR. With respect to the spatial distribution, we can also observe systematic improvement from the non-DOD to DOD models (Fig. 1D). On average, the absolute error (AE) of the non-DOD model is approximately fourfold that of the DOD model. This is underscored by the more frequent appearance of an AE ratio exceeding 1, indicating that the non-DOD model’s AE is consistently larger than that of the DOD model.

Read the rest of the open access article here.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/XEckIY2

July 26, 2024 at 04:07AM

Are we really experiencing more ‘extreme’ weather?

By Paul Homewood

 

h/t Paul Kolk

 

From the Spectator:

 

image

The UK climate is getting ever more extreme. We know this because the BBC keeps telling us so, most recently in today’s reporting of the annual Met Office/Royal Meteorological Society (RMetS) State of the Climate Report for 2023. ‘Climate change is dramatically increasing the frequency of extreme high temperatures in the UK,’ writes climate editor Justin Rowlatt on the BBC website. As well as experiencing more really hot days, ‘its observations suggest there has been an increase in the number of really wet days too, such as the prolonged and heavy rain Storm Babet brought to wide areas of the country in October last year.’ He comments: ‘The UK’s shifting climate represents a dangerous upheaval for our ecosystems as well as our infrastructure’. And in case we still haven’t got it, he adds: ‘Climate change has already made more extreme weather events, such as heatwaves, heavy rainfall, storms, and drought, more frequent and stronger in many parts of the world.’

But how much of this is really true, and how much of it – were BBC Verify minded to undertake a fair analysis of this output – is hyperbole? The State of the UK Climate Report 2023 is published today in the International Journal of Climatology, and you can read it for yourself here. But for those without the time to do this, this is what it says on the specific matters raised by Rowlatt and the BBC. Firstly, those ‘extremely high temperatures’. As far as 2023 was concerned, it turns out that actually they were rather thin on the ground. The highest temperature measured anywhere in the UK in 2023 was 33ºC in Faversham, Kent, which the report notes is rather modest by the standards of recent years. Nevertheless, it is true to say that there is an increasing trend in the frequency of hot weather in Britain. In the decade from 2014 to 23 there were 2.5 times as many days per year with temperatures exceeding 28ºC somewhere in Britain as there were during the years 1961 to 1990. There were 3.6 times as many days per year with temperatures over 32ºC.

This is consistent with the long-term trend in mean temperatures, which have also resulted in fewer very cold days. In the decade from 2014 to 2023, there were on average 17 fewer days of air frost per year than during 1961 to 1990. It is not very satisfactory comparing a ten-year period with a 30-year one, given the natural variability in the weather, but year-on-year graphs appear to confirm that Britain is experiencing more hot weather and less cold weather. That is something that needs to be borne in mind when the BBC and others claim climate change is causing more ‘extreme’ weather. The rise in extreme hot weather is balanced out by a fall in extreme cold weather.

What about the claimed rise in ‘really wet days’? The State of the Climate Report does state that overall Britain is becoming wetter, with overall rainfall ten per cent higher from 2014 to 2023 than between 1961 and 1990. But then rainfall fluctuated quite a lot decade on decade prior to the 1960s. The year 2023 was the seventh wettest year in England and Wales in a series going back to 1766. The wettest, by the way, was 1767. But ‘really wet days’? The report states that there has been a ‘slight increase in heavy rainfall across the UK in recent decades’. There are a number of metrics used to measure heavy rainfall, such as the average number of days a year with rain exceeding 10mm, the number of days when rainfall exceeds the 99th percentile, etc. All seem to tell a similar story: there was a strong upward trend in the frequency of heavy rain in Britain between the 1960s and the beginning of this century, but with little or no trend since then (figure 49 shows this).

As for the claim that the world is seeing more frequent and stronger storms – made by Rowlatt in the global rather than specifically UK context – what does the UK State of the Climate Report say about that? By recent standards, last year was a relatively stormy year. However, the frequently-made claim that Britain saw a ‘record’ number of storms last winter is based on a meaningless metric: the number of named storms. There is no consistent definition of a named storm other than that someone in the UK or Ireland Met Office’s has decided it warrants a name. Moreover, the naming of storms only began in 2015 – so not even the 1987 hurricane had a name. But the State of the Climate Report does present data on extreme wind speeds measured in the UK – namely the number of days per year on which gusts of over 40, 50, and 60 knots have been recorded somewhere in the UK. This data shows a very clear downward trend since 1990 [fig 60]. There is also data showing that mean wind speeds have been falling in Britain since 1970 – a trend that echoes that in many parts of the world. That is not very good for Ed Miliband’s wind turbines, but it is not consistent with a claim that Britain is becoming more stormy.

So, yes, we are seeing more hot weather and we are seeing more rainfall overall. But no, we are not being battered by biblical downpours or extreme weather of all kinds.

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/are-we-really-experiencing-more-extreme-weather/

.

I would add to Ross’ comments about storms that the global data shows no increase either:

.

https://notalotofpeopleknowthat.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/image-218.png

https://notalotofpeopleknowthat.wordpress.com/2024/01/25/hurricane-review-for-2023/

via NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

https://ift.tt/XHf5Mh3

July 26, 2024 at 03:40AM

Let El Paso be El Paso, and grow economically

El Paso’s economic contribution is not minor.

via CFACT

https://ift.tt/EHASVNw

July 26, 2024 at 02:44AM