Oh, the humanity! The New York Times has unearthed a scandal of apocalyptic proportions: the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) might shutter its office in Hilo, Hawaii, which oversees the Mauna Loa Observatory. Yes, that Mauna Loa—the one with the fancy Keeling Curve that’s been tracking carbon dioxide like a stalker since 1958. According to the Times’ breathless prose, this could spell doom for “global scientific research.” Cue the violins.
The story, scraped from an internal federal document like it’s some kind of Wikileaks drop, warns that the Hilo office could close as early as August. Why? Because Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has proposed slashing 793 federal leases to save a measly $500 million. That’s less than 0.1% of the 2025 defense budget, the article tut-tuts, as if every penny of government bloat is a sacred cow. Never mind that these offices might be ghost towns, abandoned by remote-working bureaucrats who’d rather Zoom from their lanais than clock in. Nope, it’s a crisis, because reasons.
The Times wrings its hands over the observatory’s fate, but here’s the kicker: there’s zero evidence Mauna Loa’s CO2 monitors will stop humming. No one’s saying the instruments get unplugged—just that the Hilo office, one of 30 NOAA buildings on DOGE’s hit list, might not be needed. Maybe the data can be managed from, say, a server in Colorado? Or a laptop in someone’s basement? But no, we’re told this is a “pole star of global scientific research,” and without that Hilo lease, the planet’s “eyes” will be gouged out. Ralph Keeling, son of the curve’s namesake, calls it “vital baseline data.” Sure, Ralph, but vital to what? Endless climate conferences and glossy charts?
The article’s real spice comes from its cast of disgruntled ex-NOAA folks. Janet Coit, former assistant administrator of NOAA Fisheries, frets that if leases end, staff might not know “whether they have an office or access to essential equipment.” More likely these offices have been empty for years as employees “worked” remotely, with some likely working a second job.
Meanwhile, John Bateman, a NOAA meteorologist, laments the end of monthly climate briefings due to staff cuts—1,300 gone, 1,000 more to go. Sounds like a leaner operation, but to hear the Times tell it, it’s the end of civilization. Who will churn out those precipitation reports we all pore over at breakfast?
And then there’s the White House Press Secretary, Karoline Leavitt, who delivers the story’s best zinger. Asked to comment, she fires back:
“As a matter of policy, we do not respond to reporters with pronouns in their bios.”
Burn. The Times, of course, plays it straight, but you can almost hear the reporter’s keyboard clattering in indignation. Pronouns or not, the lack of a juicy quote leaves the piece leaning hard on innuendo—extrapolating from a spreadsheet to a full-blown climate science Armageddon.
Naturally, the article can’t resist the obligatory climate change sermon. That rising Keeling Curve? It’s “warmed the atmosphere,” causing “more frequent and intense extreme weather events like heat waves, floods, and wildfires.” No data, no attribution studies—just vibes. Never mind that linking CO2 to specific storms is a game of statistical Twister even the IPCC plays coy about. But why let facts spoil a good narrative?
So here we are: a tale of a Hawaiian office facing the axe, spun into a dirge for “climate science”—that noble pursuit some might call taxpayer-funded navel-gazing. The Times wants you to believe every lease termination is a dagger to the heart of progress, every cut a betrayal of the planet. Yet the observatory’s still running, the curve’s still curving, and the only thing truly threatened seems to be the egos of a few ex-employees. Maybe DOGE’s onto something—trim the fat, keep the data. Or maybe it’s all just a plot to make us miss the next PowerPoint on South Sudan’s heat waves. Either way, the sky’s not falling. It’s just a little less cluttered with rent checks.
Discover more from Watts Up With That?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
via Watts Up With That?
March 15, 2025 at 12:07PM
