Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Unconventional Sign Conventions

Guest Post by Willis Eschenbach

I do a lot of work with the CERES satellite dataset. An image of their data collection system is above. From their website:

The CERES project has advanced the state-of-the-art in Earth Radiation Budget (ERB) observations through improved accuracy of the CERES instruments and extensive use of coincident higher spatial resolution spectral imager measurements on both low-Earth orbit and geostationary platforms. CERES involves a high level of data fusion. During the CERES period, the team has processed data from 7 CERES instruments, 2 MODIS, 2 VIIRS and 20 geostationary imagers, all integrated to obtain climate accuracy in radiative fluxes from the top to the bottom of the atmosphere. Over 90% of the CERES data product volume involves two or more instruments.

However, recently, there have been claims in an analysis by Nikolov and Zeller (N&Z) that the IPCC is misusing the CERES satellite data. Now, I hate to write about this analysis for reasons I’ll get into, but as the saying goes, “Needs must when the Devil drives.”

The analysis is Nikolov & Zeller: Misrepresentation of Critical Satellite Data by IPCC, and it’s hosted over at Tallbloke’s Talkshop.

The reason I didn’t want to write about it is that I’ve had run-ins with Ned Nikolov and Karl Zeller before, and also with Roger Tattersall, AKA “Tallbloke”.

With N&Z, a while back they published a scientific paper using aliases. I figured it out, which wasn’t all that hard given that the aliases were Den Volokin and Lark Rellez. So I wrote to the editor pointing this out, and the fat was in the fire. Suffice it to say, they weren’t happy with me.

They also published an analysis claiming that gravity is what is keeping the atmosphere warmer than it would be given the distance of the Earth from the sun. And that, of course, isn’t physically possible … and I said so.

With Roger Tallbloke, I’m banned from commenting on his site, Tallbloke’s Talkshop. It started with him banning Joel Shore from his site for saying that N&Z’s gravity analysis violated the conservation of energy. From a post during that time:

Roger’s exact words to Joel were:

… you’re not posting here unless and until you apologise to Nikolov and Zeller for spreading misinformation about conservation of energy in their theory all over the blogosphere and failing to correct it.

Now, I have done the very same thing that Joel did. I’ve said around the web that the N&Z theory violates conservation of energy. So I went to the Talkshop and asked, even implored, Roger not to do such a foolish and anti-scientific thing as banning someone for their scientific views. Since I hold the same views and I committed the same thought-crimes, it was more than theoretical to me. Roger has remained obdurate, however, so I am no longer able to post there in good conscience.

Then, in a separate incident, I put up an actual proof that N&Z’s claim violated conservation of energy. I’m sure that didn’t endear me to N&Z. In the comments to that post, Rog got angry at me and banned me. I guess I’m double-banned.

So me commenting on an N&Z post hosted at Tallbloke’s Talkshop … well … let me just say there are forces at play and leave it at that.

To be fair, after someone pointed the N&Z out to me a week or so ago, I did get curious and started to take a quick look at the paper. I got a few paragraphs in, laughed, and moved on. Here’s why.

N&Z’s claim in the paper is that the IPCC is totally misrepresenting the CERES data by inverting it. From the opening of the paper:

We found out that the CERES global anomalies of reflected shortwave and outgoing longwave radiation have been multiplied by -1 in the computer code employed to generate Fig. 7.3. This caused inversion of the long-term trends of these key climate parameters. Dr. Matthew Palmer, one of the authors of Section 7.2.2, admitted in an email message that this trend inversion was done intentionally, but failed to provide a convincing justification for it.

When they said that, I immediately knew what had happened. Let me explain.

In the CERES datasets, generally all fluxes are positive in sign. So for example, in the CERES dataset the average value of TOA solar radiation heading towards the Earth is + 340 W/m2, and the average value of reflected solar heading away from the Earth is + 99 W/m2. Both are positive.

However, this is not the only convention in use. The IPCC, for example, considers energy fluxes heading towards the Earth as positive, and fluxes heading away from the Earth as negative. The logic behind this is that inward fluxes warm the Earth so they should be positive, and outbound fluxes cool the Earth so they should be negative. Fair enough.

So the IPCC would say that solar radiation is + 340 W/m2, and reflected solar radiation is – 99 W/m2. The outgoing radiation is negative.

The same is true about the upwelling longwave at the top of the atmosphere. The CERES data gives that as a positive value, + 240 W/m2 … but under the IPCC convention it’s a negative value, – 240 W/m2.

There’s nothing sacred about either of these conventions. Both are perfectly valid ways of doing business. For that matter, it would also be perfectly valid to consider fluxes headed towards the Earth as negative, and those going out away from the Earth as positive.

As long as you know which convention is in operation, it’s not a problem. For example, in CERES fashion, since all flows are positive, the net solar remaining after reflection is calculated as solar minus reflection.

But using the IPCC convention, where reflection is negative, the net solar remaining after reflection is calculated as solar plus reflection.

And when you understand and follow the convention in use, both give you the correct answer.

So after reading that small bit of their paper, I could already see where the misunderstanding lay. It was just different sign conventions. And since I didn’t want to write about it, I stopped reading the analysis right there, and I went on to other things.

However, today Anthony asked me to take a look at the paper because it seems to be causing a bit of a disturbance in the force. So it was “Once more into the breach, dear friends”, and I read it to the end. And near the end, to my surprise, they discussed their interaction with the authors, viz

We received a reply from Dr. Palmer on July 10, 2024, where he acknowledged that the reflected solar and outgoing thermal flux anomalies had intentionally been multiplied by -1. However, his explanation for this data manipulation was simply an expansion of the justification stated in the caption of Fig. 7.3 that invokes flux direction. Specifically, Dr. Palmer wrote:

“… reflected SW and outgoing LW are both defined as positive in the upward/outward direction. Therefore, for those timeseries we multiply by -1 so that they are expressed in a way that is consistent with the rest of the chapter. This means, for example, that a decrease in reflected SW means a relative GAIN of energy in the Earth system. Similarly, an increase in outgoing LW means a relative LOSS of energy in the Earth system. Note that in the figure we label these as “global solar flux anomaly” and “global thermal flux anomaly” rather than “reflected SW flux” and “outgoing LW flux”.”

Man, did I laugh when I read that. It said the exact same thing I’d already figured out was the problem. However, N&Z just blew him off saying:

As discussed above, this explanation makes no physical sense, because anomalies are always defined with respect to a chosen reference value and, therefore, have nothing to do with flux direction. Also, expressing a timeseries in terms of anomalies is not supposed to change the temporal trend of the original data.

Yeah … no. That’s not how it works. Sign conventions are just that, a convention. All the authors did, and rightly so, was to make their analysis consistent with IPCC conventions and more importantly, consistent with the model results they were comparing it to, by multiplying the outgoing flows of shortwave and longwave by -1. Totally legitimate, and in their case, totally necessary.

Anyhow, that’s N&Z, wrong again. However, my guess is that they won’t admit it, they’ll just keep on keeping on.

And that’s all I’m going to say on the N&Z claim. Here on our forested hillside with a tiny view of the Pacific Ocean six miles (ten km) distant to the west, the temperature has dropped and the fog is back. Saw a red fox scurrying by today looking for his lunch … life is good.

My best to all.

w.

I gotta say it: When you comment, please quote the exact words you are discussing. It avoids endless misunderstandings.

NB: Today at the time when this publishes, I’ll be ripping the innards out of a toilet and taking them to town to find a replacement … so my replies will be delayed.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/lHeokXs

August 1, 2024 at 12:04PM

New Study: ‘Widespread Increase’ In Plant Transpiration Driven By Increasing CO2 Concentration

“…higher atmospheric CO2…triggers…increased vegetation production and a greener landscape”  – Chen et al., 2024

Plant transpiration is vital to plant growth and terrestrial ecosystems.

The rising CO2 trend over the last 30 years (1990-2020) has been the primary driver of planetary greening, or increases in Leaf Area Index (LAI).

The greening, in turn, is predominantly responsible for the widespread increase in plant transpiration over this period.

These elevated trends in greening and plant transpiration are expected to continue unabated to 2100, accelerating with the increases in emissions.

“The trend attribution analysis results show that the change in leaf area index (LAI) can explain 66.2% of the global PT trend, indicating that elevated LAI due to global greening is the dominant factor contributing to the upward trend in global PT. The elevated LAI can be largely attributed to the CO2 fertilization effect induced by elevated atmospheric CO2 concentration.”

Image Source: Chen et al., 2024

via NoTricksZone

https://ift.tt/3Earix2

August 1, 2024 at 10:51AM

Arctic Ice Slight Deficit July 31, 2024

 

The graph above shows July daily ice extents for 2024 compared to 18 year averages, and some years of note.

The black line shows on average Arctic ice extents during July decline 2.7M km2 down to 6.9M Km2 by day 213.  2024  tracked a litter higher than the 18-year average early in Jul7, then slipped into deficit in the last 10 days.  SII was close to MASIE early in July, then diverged mid month showing up to 666k km2 lower until July ~300k km2 less extent than MASIE.  2023 was higher than average, while 2007 ended ~ 540k km2 in deficit to average.  2020 ice started nearly 1 Wadham or 1M km2 in deficit.

Why is this important?  All the claims of global climate emergency depend on dangerously higher temperatures, lower sea ice, and rising sea levels.  The lack of additional warming prior to 2023 El Nino is documented in a post UAH June 2024: Oceans Lead Cool Down.

The lack of acceleration in sea levels along coastlines has been discussed also.  See Observed vs. Imagined Sea Levels 2023 Update.

Also, a longer term perspective is informative:

post-glacial_sea_levelThe table below shows the distribution of Sea Ice on day 213 across the Arctic Regions, on average, this year and 2007. At this point in the year, Bering and Okhotsk seas are open water and thus dropped from the table.

Region 2024213 Day 213 Ave. 2024-Ave. 2007213 2024-2007
 (0) Northern_Hemisphere 6634637 6882380 -247743 6344860 289777
 (1) Beaufort_Sea 717847 791600 -73754 760576 -42729
 (2) Chukchi_Sea 702720 534093 168628 382350 320370
 (3) East_Siberian_Sea 760894 740772 20122 445385 315509
 (4) Laptev_Sea 223615 368247 -144631 314382 -90767
 (5) Kara_Sea 136159 163171 -27012 239232 -103073
 (6) Barents_Sea 454 31406 -30952 23703 -23249
 (7) Greenland_Sea 237168 294526 -57358 324737 -87570
 (8) Baffin_Bay_Gulf_of_St._Lawrence 170245 145062 25183 94179 76066
 (9) Canadian_Archipelago 454695 540106 -85411 510063 -55368
 (10) Hudson_Bay 129434 133138 -3704 93655 35780
 (11) Central_Arctic 3098283 3138628 -40345 3154837 -56554

The overall deficit to average is 248k km2, (4%).  The major deficits are in Laptev, Beaufort and CAA (Canadian Archipelago), while Kara is the only region with a large surplus.

bathymetric_map_arctic_ocean

Illustration by Eleanor Lutz shows Earth’s seasonal climate changes. If played in full screen, the four corners present views from top, bottom and sides. It is a visual representation of scientific datasets measuring ice and snow extents.

There is no charge for content on this site, nor for subscribers to receive email notifications of postings.

 

via Science Matters

https://ift.tt/bfP92IE

August 1, 2024 at 10:44AM

Friday

0 out of 10 based on 0 rating

via JoNova

https://ift.tt/RWYp057

August 1, 2024 at 10:18AM