Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Wednesday

0 out of 10 based on 0 rating

via JoNova

https://ift.tt/TUunHj5

July 30, 2024 at 09:55AM

Don Ritter: The Green New Deal may decide the election — in the Republicans’ favor

Embed from Getty Images Sen. John Fetter­man has in­di­cated that en­ergy would not be in the fore­front of Penn­syl­va­nians’ vot­ing de­ci­sions this year, but he may not be ac­count­ing for its re­la­tion to in­fla­tion. In­fla­tion ranks as cru­cially im­por­tant, a top con­cern of the vot­ing pub­lic in the 2024 elec­tion. While the en­ergy is­sue had […]

via CFACT

https://ift.tt/CV56hi2

July 30, 2024 at 08:34AM

GWPF welcomes Charity Commission’s findings

By Paul Homewood

 

 The Left resort to lawfare to stymie opposition.

This latest attempt to strip the GWPF of charity status was always bogus. The Good Law Project is run by the notorious Jolyon Maugham who seems to have lost every case he has started against right wing organisations:

 

 

 

 

London, 30 July: The Global Warming Policy Foundation has welcomed the Charity Commission’s decision to close its compliance review after looking at complaints submitted by the Good Law Project.
The Commission examined a range of areas, including the GWPF’s research and publication review process, its funding sources and its relationships with Net Zero Watch and with the American Friends of the GWPF.
It noted our introduction of an open peer review process for our publications and the procedures in place to ensure that Net Zero Watch does not impact on our charitable purpose.
It also examined concerns that the charity was financially supporting Net Zero Watch and said it “found no evidence to back these concerns up.”
The Charity Commission has accepted assurances from the trustees that the GWPF does not accept donations from the energy industry or anyone with a significant interest in an energy company.
Dr Jerome Booth, chairman of the Global Warming Policy Foundation said:
“There are those who employ moral reasoning with little respect for opposing views. Sometimes they employ heavy handed means to shut down debate and persecute and attack anyone with whom they disagree.  When they happen to be wrong this can seriously hamper good decisions and policy making. 
This educational charity was set up to help generate an informed and rational debate on energy and climate policies for the greater public good.  We welcome the Commission’s findings and will continue to pursue our charitable objectives.” 
Charity Commission’s statement

via NOT A LOT OF PEOPLE KNOW THAT

https://ift.tt/zRNGIX2

July 30, 2024 at 08:28AM

“Missing Context”: How Climate Catastrophists at NOAA Mislead without Lying

by E. Calvin Beisner

By now practically everyone who follows news and commentary about climate change has seen graphs of global warming over the past century or more. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) produced this one in 2017, covering 1880–2016.

Ever since it first appeared, it’s been one of the most commonly used, whether in scholarly journals or government websites or news media or blogs or social media. More recent data generally are communicated similarly—and it’s not hard to understand why.

Here, solid bars, one for each year, depict the change in global average temperature (depicted as anomalies, i.e., departures, from the 20th-century average), and the psychological impact is predictable: fear.

How? Bars in the early years, below the average, are a comforting blue; later bars, above average, are an alarming red. If all the bars were the same color, the psychological impact of the different colors would be lost.

But the color choices aren’t all. They’re just the most obvious. Another choice is less obvious, and readers unfamiliar with how to interpret graphic representations (or misrepresentations) of data are likely not to notice it.

Ominously, the longest blue bars reach almost to the bottom of the graph, and the longest red ones almost to the top. Why? Because the vertical axis chosen (and note that word—it’s a definite choice) covers only from -0.5°C to +1.0°C (-0.9°F to +1.8°F). A grand total of 1.5°C (2.7°F).

On the one hand, this is quite defensible. Enter the raw numbers into common spreadsheet software, tell it to produce a bar graph, and that, or something very close to it, is what you’ll get. And why not? After all, it accommodates all the numbers, lowest to highest. What more can we ask?

On the other hand—if your intent is to help people think reasonably about changing global temperature, it’s utterly indefensible.

Why? Because it makes a temperature variation of under 1.5°C (2.7°F) look, to the unpracticed eye, far more significant than it is. After all, most people hardly notice if a room’s temperature rises or falls that much. But on this vertical scale, the longest red bars reach almost to the top, as if to say, “We’re about to reach the maximum!” True, the longest blue bars also reach almost to the bottom, which could be interpreted, “Whew! We just barely missed freezing!” (And since cold snaps kill, on average, 10 to 20 times as many people per day as heat waves, that should be really comforting—but I digress.)

But remember, blue’s a comforting color; red routinely means “danger!” That, after all, is why United Nations Secretary-General António Guterrez called the first volume of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s Sixth Assessment Report “code red for humanity,” not “code blue” (though, admittedly, in a hospital “code blue” denotes a critical status of a patient—but that’s not common lingo).

And since most people read from left to right, the graph subtly communicates that, whatever risks might have come with those low temperatures, we’ve left them far behind. No need to worry about them now. It’s those high temperatures, marching inexorably upward, that we need to worry about.

Back in the early 1990s, when I was managing editor of the book The State of Humanity, its general editor, the late economist and statistician Julian L. Simon, legendary for his antipathy to misleading statistical graphs, insisted that all graphs of the data provided by the 58 authors (including 8 Nobel Prize winners) use a realistic, objective scale.

For example, graphs of data expressed as percent should have a vertical scale of a full 100 points—otherwise, the result could be highly deceptive. After all, if the vertical scale only went from 80% to 90%, a data point of 86% could appear to depict a quantity twice as high as 83%, when in reality it’s only 3.6% higher.

Another example: Graphs of data that don’t depict percents should have a zero baseline. Or, if they depict both negative and positive data, the vertical axis should stretch equally far below and above zero, so the relative magnitudes would be quickly and easily comprehensible. Or, if they depict data so enormously different that low numbers just disappear, they should be drawn with exponential scales—and that fact should be communicated prominently—or with clearly marked discontinuities along the vertical axis.

There are other examples, but you get the point. One of the basic principles is that the vertical axis should cover a truly significant range.

That’s the bigger problem with NOAA’s famous graph. As we saw above, it makes a very small change in temperature appear much larger and more significant.

A more appropriate, less misleading, way to graph the same temperature data is to use a vertical range that’s fairly typical of the weather people commonly experience. That’s a scale they’ll understand.

In the United States, except when air currents rapidly move a much warmer (or cooler) air mass from one locale to another, diurnal (daytime high to nighttime low) temperature range is typically around 5.6°C (10°F) in humid locales but around 22.2°C to 27.8°C (40°F to 50°F) in arid to semi-arid locales. In other words, people are accustomed to those temperature ranges.

It would seem reasonable, then, to depict global temperature anomaly data on a vertical scale of, say, halfway between the low and high ranges, i.e., 16.7°C (30°F). And, to complete our avoidance of psychological scare tactics, we’ll jettison the color scheme and use a neutral color.

How would NOAA’s data for 1880 to 2016 look depicted that way? Like this:

Remember, this depicts exactly the same data depicted in NOAA’s graph. Does it look scary? No, but it’s a much more honest, objective, non-manipulative depiction of the data. So, now you’re equipped not to be manipulated—and to enlighten your friends and neighbors.

Defenders of the scary way to depict the data could respond, “But the fact is that this apparently slight change in global average temperature will, if it continues at scale, cause devastating changes in weather, sea level, crop production, and other measures—changes that will impoverish humanity and possibly even bring about its extinction. So scary depiction of scary facts is just what we need.”

But the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change disagrees—firmly and adamantly. Its 2018 Special Report on Global Warming of 1.8°C concludes that if we do nothing to slow greenhouse gas-induced warming, the warming will make gross world product (GWP) in 2100 will be 2.6 percent lower it otherwise would be.

What would it otherwise be? The Center for Global Development says economic growth through the remainder of this century is most likely to be about 3 percent per year. After factoring in change in population, the result would be GWP per capita 8.8 times what it was in 2018.

When poverty is a far greater threat to human health and life than anything related to climate and weather, can anyone think that’s a catastrophic result?

If you spend much time at all on social media sites on which people often post text or pictures meant to make points about controversial issues, you’re bound to have seen “fact checks” stating that a post conveyed “false or misleading information” because it was “missing context.” (That’s a judgment that’s often subjective and driven by the “fact checker’s” ideology, but we can ignore that for now). What you now know is that, when it comes to “missing context” about climate change, official government agencies can be among the worst offenders, not just on social media but also on agency websites—from which their products, like the NOAA graph evaluated here, regularly make their way into scientific journals and mainstream media.

A Google image search July 11, 2024, found NOAA’s graph at about 100 sites. Where are those “fact checkers” when we need them?

E. Calvin Beisner, Ph.D., is President of The Cornwall Alliance for the Stewardship of Creation, a Christian think tank addressing environmental stewardship and economic development for the poor. He is also co-editor, with David R. Legates, Ph.D., of Climate and Energy: The Case for Realism, an Amazon bestseller.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/9H5TKQR

July 30, 2024 at 08:07AM