Author: Iowa Climate Science Education

Oil & Gas Producers Making Massive Profits From Intermittent Wind & Solar

 

Oil and gas producers are making a killing thanks to chaotically intermittent wind and solar, providing fuel to run gas and diesel generators as so-called ‘backup’.

Mike Holly apparently doesn’t like monopolies and has a set against hydrocarbons. However, he makes a fair point targeting oil and gas producers making a killing every time wind and solar output collapses (sunset and/or calm and cloudy weather will do it every time).

For every MW of wind and solar capacity, there’s a MW of fast-start, peaking power generator capacity waiting in the wings. The owners of those ‘peakers’ – open cycle gas turbines, diesel and kerosene-fuelled generators – cash in at power consumers’ expense.

Noting the way that this has been engineered around the globe (as Mike Holly does below), you don’t need to be a cynic to conclude that the so-called ‘wind and solar transition’ was really designed by crony capitalists to enjoy extraordinary financial gain.

Mike points out that the wind and solar industry’s claims about reducing carbon oxide gas emissions in the electricity generation sector are complete bunkum.

Exposed Global Conspiracy Was Hiding Big Backup Problem of Wind and Solar
Americans Against Monopolies
Mike Holly
19 June 2024

Many global governments, led by the U.S., European Union (EU) and China, are favouring and building wind and solar energy, and incentivizing and pressuring other countries to do the same. U.S. preferential policies include mandates, manufacturing and generation tax subsidies, and regulations rewarding unreliable generation, such as competitive bidding, wholesale markets and low-cost transmission. Global governments have even conspired to hide the reduced fuel efficiencies of the natural gas generators needed to follow wind and solar energy, and misrepresent the reductions in greenhouse gas emissions attributed to these energy sources. The conspiracy of silence has finally been exposed by an electricity industry engineer and a Norwegian study. The governments can now be held even more responsible for high oil and natural gas usage, future energy crises and climate change (i.e., if that exists and is caused by humans).

For example, the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) has used only fuel consumption data to attribute 65% of the decline in theoretical U.S. carbon dioxide emissions to the shift from coal- to natural gas-fired electricity generation, and 30% to the increase in wind and solar generation. They have ignored well-known methane leaks from oil and gas fracking that greatly increase the greenhouse effect, perhaps enough to negate the benefits of shifting from coal. Less well known and even more significant, governments and government-franchised utility monopolies have been hiding the data needed to determine the fuel efficiencies of the gas generation used to backup wind and solar energy.

The intermittent output from wind and solar energy can be followed far more economically with natural gas generators. Obviously, the typical capacity factors of wind and solar energy of under 50% means the renewable energy replaces less than half of the gas generation needed for backup. But an even bigger problem is the intermittent output from wind and solar has forced the gas generators to ramp up and down at lower fuel efficiencies, and replace much less gas than being reported.

The shift from coal to natural gas was driven by aging plants, environmental regulations, fuel efficiencies, costs, and backup of wind and solar. U.S. generation fueled by natural gas increased from 19% in 2005 to 41% in 2020, with perhaps half of the increase now following wind and solar. Older gas plants average about 45% fuel efficiency. The most efficient combined cycle natural gas plants entering service since 2014 have the potential for fuel efficiencies of up to about 60%. Yet, overall gas efficiency increased from 37 to 43 percent between 2000 to 2010, and then plateaued when the most efficient plants were coming online. This plateauing correlates with the increase in wind generation from 2.3% in 2010 to 10.2% in 2022.

In the May 10, 2023 article of The Telegraph entitled “The wind and solar power myth has finally been exposed,” electricity industry engineer Bryan Leyland explains that countries with a considerable amount of wind and solar generation have started following the unpredictable fluctuations of power from the renewable energy by replacing efficient combined-cycle gas turbine plants with open-cycle gas turbines that burn about twice as much gas (note: utilities have been known to disconnect the second turbine of combined-cycle plants). Leyland effectively throws cold water on hopes for technological breakthroughs with electricity storage and calls it madness that governments are expecting to build more wind and solar until net carbon emissions are reduced to zero.

But perhaps the best evidence of the conspiracy comes from a recent Norwegian scientific study of the electricity grid in Ireland entitled “Wind power is not sustainable when fossil balancing power is taken into account.” They analyzed the grid in Ireland because they have high wind speeds and market penetration, and were offered rare access to the necessary data. They found that wind energy was actually reducing emissions from gas plants by only 10 to 20 percent, compared to 20 to 40 percent claimed in typical publications. The Norwegian study concluded: “Over the last 20 years, humanity has reduced its share of fossil primary energy consumption by using wind and solar power by merely 4 percentage points after spending more than 3 trillion USD. This says it all.”

Strangely, the Norwegian study doesn’t explicitly state that the reduction of emissions was limited by the lower fuel efficiencies of the gas generators used for backup. But the author claims as much in the comment section of his linked-in article. And while $3 trillion is a lot of money, it is 3.2% of global public debt. The failure to diversify from oil and natural gas usage could be much more expensive for the global economy, if it results in future energy crises and/or climate change. Every added unit of wind energy is forcing the future use of at least a similar unit of gas generation AND at a fraction of the efficiency. U.S. oil and natural gas production were declining from 1970 to 2005, before the government granted environmental exemptions to fracking. With production from fracking now expected to decline in the next few years, it isn’t clear what can take its place.

The problem with governments is likely political (and not madness), while government-franchised utility monopolies favor utility-scale wind and solar because their energy sources are controlled by government and profits increase with spending. U.S. Congressional Republicans and utility monopolies wouldn’t even respond to requests for the data needed to determine the fuel efficiencies of the gas plants used to backup wind and solar energy. In Germany, utility engineers won’t allow the use of their data and have received promotions after pretending that the government’s energy transition (Energiewende) actually works. China doesn’t even bother to try to use much of its wind and solar energy. Brazil responded to questions about backup from natural gas by studying backup with hydropower, despite environmental and other concerns.

The global conspiracy also includes other interests that benefit from the perception that wind and solar reduce natural gas usage and carbon emissions. The environmental movement benefits from donations and overwhelms due diligence by sending a constant barrage of propaganda promoting wind and solar, including exaggerated claims of backup with batteries and the eventual construction of a pie-in-the-sky national grid electrified only by wind, hydropower and solar. The Big Banks are controlled by the “woke” policies of the Democratic Party and receive preferential subsidies encouraging their financing and ownership of wind and solar generators in the U.S., along with low-interest money from the Federal Reserve Bank. Wind and solar manufacturing in China and the U.S. are also controlled and subsidized by the government.

The U.S., European Union (EU) and China and their global organizations have been incentivizing and pressuring developing countries to favor wind and solar energy. Examples include: (1) the Biden administration gave First Solar, a solar energy company owned by a Biden megadonor, a $500 million government loan to build a manufacturing facility in India, (2) China has made wind and solar manufacturing and other investments in Brazil in exchange for favoring wind and solar generation over co-generation at domestic sugar cane ethanol plants that could have readily and economically reduced both oil and natural gas usage and greenhouse gas emissions, and (3) inspired by Germany, the United Nations and World Bank have been financing wind, hydro and solar energy in Africa, including Kenya and Nigeria.

Perhaps, the biggest indication of a global conspiracy is that Big Oil & Gas interests rarely mention the low reductions in natural gas usage caused by wind and solar energy, probably because it is great for their business. They often call wind and solar a pipe dream while opposing the supposed transition with relatively minor criticisms, such as land and mineral usage, capacity factors, reliability and blackouts. Government policies favoring wind and solar energy are providing political cover, that attempts are being made to solve depleting oil and natural gas reserves and climate change, while not actually threatening their $4 trillion per year global markets. The U.S. and EU obtain two-thirds of total energy from oil and by-product natural gas and less than 13% from each coal and nuclear, compared to global energy use of 54% oil and gas, 27% coal and 6% nuclear.

Manipulation of oil and natural gas supplies has caused global oil crises and threatened entire economies and even war. Global oil production has been controlled by the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and Russia (OPEC plus), which produces over half of global oil supply and has the world’s lowest-cost petroleum reserves. But the U.S., which produces over 20% of oil and natural gas, has also made these markets more dominant by favoring Big Oil & Gas companies. Global trade policies allow OPEC to prevent their citizens from producing oil and manipulate supply on global markets. Oil price spikes have led to 10 of the last 12 U.S. recessions. Governments have also claimed climate change poses an “existential threat” to life on Earth, although the seriousness of those claims now appears dubious considering government favouritism for oil and gas.
Americans Against Monopolies

via STOP THESE THINGS

https://ift.tt/lsDo7Bf

July 26, 2024 at 02:30AM

To make EV’s our battery bandaid for a wounded grid we need another $10b in inverters

To make EV’s our battery bandaid for a wounded grid we need another $10b in inverters

EV towing a trailer load of cash

By Jo Nova

The government has this hope that homeowners can be tricked into paying for the batteries (in the form of EVs) that the wind and solar industry need to make their useless random energy into something reliable. Now comes the news that not only are batteries hazardous fire risks and expensive themselves, but to connect to our grid in a two way arrangement we need to spend $3,000 dollars per household (or maybe $10,000) to buy the bit of equipment that makes this work. Not to mention adding another million gigawatts of generation so the cars can be charged in the first place.

Remember in the end, we are not buying EV’s because they go further, cost less, or are more convenient, we’re buying them because we want to stop storms in 100 years.

How many nice weather days will I get in 2100AD for that $3,000 inverter?

By Natasha Schmidt, The Australian

Interim Director of Monash Energy Institute, Roger Dargaville, said powering EVs in just one million households could cost as much as $10bn in power inverters.

Professor Dargaville said such inverters, unlike home batteries such as Tesla’s Powerwall, would allow EV drivers to recontribute power into the grid.

“That piece of infrastructure costs about $10,000 at the moment, and if you have a million vehicles sometime in the future trying to do this that’s $10bn,” he said.

Prof Dargaville hopes that mass production might reduce the cost to $3,000 each if we are lucky. (Mass money printing and inflation will probably prevent that.)

Historians will look back on this era and describe it as a case study in corruption and mass delusion. The great capitalist free market of Adam Smith exists only in limited pockets that masquerade as “free choice”.

 

 

0 out of 10 based on 0 rating

via JoNova

https://ift.tt/rdyHwmV

July 26, 2024 at 02:28AM

UK NEW LABOUR GOVERNMENT ENERGY POLICY EXPOSED

A new video by Paul Burgess exposes the madness of the net zero policy of the new government. A policy driven by Ed Miliband.  

The Nightmare of Ed Miliband’s Net Zero (youtube.com)

via climate science

https://ift.tt/OZHBe7L

July 26, 2024 at 01:56AM

Claim: Global Warming is Messing with our Rainfall

Essay by Eric Worrall

“… But it is not clear how much of this remarkable regional increase in severe rains is due to climate change, or how widespread it is …”

Landmark new research shows how global warming is messing with our rainfall

Published: July 26, 2024 6.20am AEST
Steven Sherwood Professor of Atmospheric Sciences, Climate Change Research Centre, UNSW Sydney
Anna Ukkola ARC DECRA Fellow, UNSW Sydney

The past century of human-induced warming has increased rainfall variability over 75% of the Earth’s land area – particularly over Australia, Europe and eastern North America, new research shows. 

The findings, by Chinese researchers and the UK Met Office, were published overnight in the journal Science. They provide the first systematic observational evidence that climate change is making global rainfall patterns more volatile.

Climate models had predicted this variability would worsen under climate change. But these new findings show rainfall variability has already worsened over the past 100 years – especially in Australia.

…

Analysis of daily extreme rainfall totals across Australia in present and future simulations revealed future increases were likely to exceed expectations from many past studies. Rainfall is likely to increase more sharply in the most extreme events, and appears to do this nearly everywhere on the continent.

In 2022, we looked at rainfall hour-by-hour in Sydney using radar data. We found the maximum hourly rainfall increased by 40% in Sydney over the past two decades.

Our findings have major implications for Sydney’s preparedness for flash flooding. More intense downpours are likely to overwhelm stormwater systems designed for past conditions. But it is not clear how much of this remarkable regional increase in severe rains is due to climate change, or how widespread it is.

Increasing variability also means a greater risk of drought. Climate models suggest rainfall variability in many parts of Australia will keep increasing, unless greenhouse gas emissions are rapidly reduced. 

A change in only a handful of heavy rainfall days can make or break a drought in Australia. This means even small changes in variability can bring more devastating droughts in the future as dry periods become drier.

…

Read more: https://theconversation.com/landmark-new-research-shows-how-global-warming-is-messing-with-our-rainfall-233432

The rainfall variability study;

Anthropogenic amplification of precipitation variability over the past century

WENXIA ZHANG, TIANJUN ZHOU, AND PEILI WU
SCIENCE
25 Jul 2024
Vol 385, Issue 6707

pp. 427-432

Editor’s summary

As climate change continues, warming of the atmosphere allows it to hold more water and thus produce more precipitation. A corollary to more rain is the amplification of precipitation variability, a behavior easier to predict than to observe. Zhang et al. used global records of daily precipitation to show that this expected increase in precipitation variability is in fact detectable in the data over the past century. This trend, which is most prominent over Europe, Australia, and eastern North America, will make adaptation more difficult for societies and ecosystems. —Jesse Smith

Abstract

As the climate warms, the consequent moistening of the atmosphere increases extreme precipitation. Precipitation variability should also increase, producing larger wet-dry swings, but that is yet to be confirmed observationally. Here we show that precipitation variability has already grown globally (over 75% of land area) over the past century, as a result of accumulated anthropogenic warming. The increased variability is seen across daily to intraseasonal timescales, with daily variability increased by 1.2% per 10 years globally, and is particularly prominent over Europe, Australia, and eastern North America. Increased precipitation variability is driven mainly by thermodynamics linked to atmospheric moistening, modulated at decadal timescales by circulation changes. Amplified precipitation variability poses new challenges for weather and climate predictions, as well as for resilience and adaptation by societies and ecosystems.

Read more: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adp0212

Another of the referenced studies;

Robust Future Changes in Meteorological Drought in CMIP6 Projections Despite Uncertainty in Precipitation

Anna M. Ukkola, Martin G. De Kauwe, Michael L. Roderick, Gab Abramowitz, Andrew J. Pitman
First published: 10 May 2020

Abstract

Quantifying how climate change drives drought is a priority to inform policy and adaptation planning. We show that the latest Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) simulations project coherent regional patterns in meteorological drought for two emissions scenarios to 2100. We find robust projected changes in seasonal drought duration and frequency (robust over >45% of the global land area), despite a lack of agreement across models in projected changes in mean precipitation (24% of the land area). Future drought changes are larger and more consistent in CMIP6 compared to CMIP5. We find regionalized increases and decreases in drought duration and frequency that are driven by changes in both precipitation mean and variability. Conversely, drought intensity increases over most regions but is not simulated well historically by the climate models. The more robust projections of meteorological drought compared to mean precipitation in CMIP6 provides significant new opportunities for water resource planning.

Read more: https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2020GL087820

The models don’t agree but they think some of their model predictions are reliable.

This seems a very short timeframe to call global warming as the culprit. Not only are there other confounding factors, such as massive land use changes, including vastly expanded irrigation and emission of dust and exhaust particulates, and some major volcanic eruptions such as Hunga Tonga, there is plenty of evidence of huge century scale shifts in rainfall which occurred well before anthropogenic warming became a potential issue.

Perhaps when climate scientists stop making so many wrong predictions we can pay more attempt to what their uncomfortably divergent models predict.

Meanwhile local city administrations should be spending more money on drains anyway, even without this prediction of worsening floods. That day in 2023 while I was driving through the Sydney floods I saw a sight I’ll never forget – a council worker in flood water up to his waistline bashing at a large blocked drain under his feet with a huge pry bar, to try to save an entire street of houses from the flood. I don’t see how that kind of risky emergency action would ever be necessary if the city had done a proper job of maintaining the drains BEFORE the floods hit. I sure hope he wasn’t injured that day.

via Watts Up With That?

https://ift.tt/OjGCnHy

July 26, 2024 at 12:02AM